Firearms Talk banner

1 - 20 of 23 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
2 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I just got my concealed weapons permit recently (for obvious political reasons) and I carry a .357 magnum. I got an HKS speed loader to go with it and I am not hugely impressed. I understand that the nature of reloading a revolver is inherently slower than something like a 1911. But the bullets wobble inside the loader and sometimes I have to shake the loader to get the rounds in the cylinder. Are their speed loaders that don't have these kinds of issues? And more importantly, are there other negative sides to speed loaders that I am not seeing? Everyones input would be greatly appreciated.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
51 Posts
Why do u need a speed loader if u end up using ur gun the average distance of a engagement will be like 5 to 7 feet if u can't stop the guy with less than 2 round or if u can't shoot that well ur more of a danger to the public if ur shooting at someone and should be carrying a weapon (no need for a speed loader)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
28 Posts
I carry a revolver and ditched speedloaders for speedstrips a while ago. A little practice and they're almost as fast as speedloaders, plus they're a hell of a lot easier to carry every day. If you've never used them I recommend checking them out. They are very inexpensive, so not much invested if you decide you don't like them.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
268 Posts
If they're available for your gun, try the SafariLand loaders.

Instead of a big silver twist knob on top, they're spring loaded & latched ... so you feed the rounds into the cylinder and push to release 'em. Very quick and clean.

I used them for Python & other Colts and a S&W M27 & 586.

They cost a little more but they are that much better then the HKS (IMO).
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,672 Posts
Why do u need a speed loader if u end up using ur gun the average distance of a engagement will be like 5 to 7 feet if u can't stop the guy with less than 2 round or if u can't shoot that well ur more of a danger to the public if ur shooting at someone and should be carrying a weapon (no need for a speed loader)
If you dont mind me asking what weapon do you conseal?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
28 Posts
Why do u need a speed loader if u end up using ur gun the average distance of a engagement will be like 5 to 7 feet if u can't stop the guy with less than 2 round or if u can't shoot that well ur more of a danger to the public if ur shooting at someone and should be carrying a weapon (no need for a speed loader)
This is an absolutely awful reply. In more ways than one.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,626 Posts
I would say plus one on the speed strips. I always found that when using a speed loader not inserting the rounds all the way when using the speed loader allows for them to drop much quicker into the cylinder. I would stick the in 1/3 way and turn the lock to let them drop in.
It's not perfect and then again maybe that's why I sold my S&W mod 60.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,254 Posts
There is no comparison between speed loaders and speed strips. Speed loaders are much faster. I used to compete with a 586. I used the HSK and Safariland brands, Safariland is a big step up. I highly recomend them.

Speed loaders do take practice. I used to practice by having 3 speedloaders full of dummy rounds. You could use snap caps. Do not use live rounds. I would have the loaders on my belt and the gun already loaded with the dummies. I would draw, empty the cylinder, reload, empty the cylinder, reload, empty the cylinder, reload.
I would do this over and over again.

I would never advise someone else to not carry a reload.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,458 Posts
There is no comparison between speed loaders and speed strips. Speed loaders are much faster. I used to compete with a 586. I used the HSK and Safariland brands, Safariland is a big step up. I highly recomend them.

Speed loaders do take practice. I used to practice by having 3 speedloaders full of dummy rounds. You could use snap caps. Do not use live rounds. I would have the loaders on my belt and the gun already loaded with the dummies. I would draw, empty the cylinder, reload, empty the cylinder, reload, empty the cylinder, reload.
I would do this over and over again.

I would never advise someone else to not carry a reload.

I recently got a good deal on a used pair of speedloaders for my ruger. Ive been practicing a little but using live rounds sketches me out too much to try it fast. Do you have a lead on dummy 357/38spl rounds?
 

·
Administrator
Joined
·
26,448 Posts
Speedstrips. Yes, they are slower- but they lay flat in a pocket, and my speed loaders do not. Do I carry reloads? Oh HELL yes! I still carry a Mdl 36 on a lot of days. 5 shots.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
667 Posts
I recently got a good deal on a used pair of speedloaders for my ruger. Ive been practicing a little but using live rounds sketches me out too much to try it fast. Do you have a lead on dummy 357/38spl rounds?
Look on Amazon.com under 38 snap caps
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,178 Posts
Ive been practicing a little but using live rounds sketches me out too much to try it fast. Do you have a lead on dummy 357/38spl rounds?
Get some snap caps they are cheap, or if you reload or know someone who does you could make yourself some dummies, just stick a bullet on a empty case.

Springfield XDM 45 5.25 competiton is a little bulky but amazing and accurate
What does this have to do with speed loaders? :confused:
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
18,636 Posts
What does this have to do with speed loaders? :confused:
Nothing. He made a pretty... strange statement and was asked what he carries. Apparently if you can't neutralize a threat with one shot then you're a menace to society. Says the guy carrying a gun that (I think) comes standard with a 13 round mag. That's 13 bad guys, one shot, one kill. Must be one helluva an "operator".
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
7,777 Posts
I carry a revolver and ditched speedloaders for speedstrips a while ago. A little practice and they're almost as fast as speedloaders, plus they're a hell of a lot easier to carry every day. If you've never used them I recommend checking them out. They are very inexpensive, so not much invested if you decide you don't like them.
You beat me to it. I have been carrying them for 30+ years when I carry a revolver. :D
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
850 Posts
Speedstrips. Yes, they are slower- but they lay flat in a pocket, and my speed loaders do not. Do I carry reloads? Oh HELL yes! I still carry a Mdl 36 on a lot of days. 5 shots.
S&w 36? My favorite snubby of all time, wish i had the money to get one.

Back to topic, what, if any, is the size difference between the hk and safariland speed loaders?

Also to op: ive noticed the same issue, i went to putting 38 +p cartridges in my speed loaders, made it a bit easier to reload the revolver for me.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
341 Posts
I have used both and my preference is speed strips. With some practice you will be able to reload as fast with the strips as you can with the speed loaders. The strips are easier to carry and allow you to load empty chambers while you still have still have live rounds in the gun. Take my advice for what its worth. Your mileage may vary.
 
1 - 20 of 23 Posts
Top