USP .45 vs. XD .45

Discussion in 'General Handgun Discussion' started by thesmiter1, Feb 14, 2009.

  1. thesmiter1

    thesmiter1 New Member

    Which is the better weapon? The USP gets 12 to a mag, and the XD gets 13, so that's not really an issue to me. The question is: which one is the altogether better weapon? This goes in terms of reliability, longevity, accuracy, and so on. Thanks for any answers!:)
  2. stalkingbear

    stalkingbear Well-Known Member

    It would be a tough decision between these 2, but I'd personally rather have the XD. I like the trigger on XDs that have been tuned, they have grip safety, and still offer available manual safety. There's a rapidly growing aftermarket business evolving around the XD, and since I rarely leave a handgun as is, the XD gets the nod.

  3. thesmiter1

    thesmiter1 New Member

    I'm new to handguns. I only have experience with machine guns and assault rifles, so I don't know much about modifying them, but I'm sure I'll learn. Thank you for your reply.
  4. Bighead

    Bighead Member

    I would say the XD(m) 45 ACP. Oh wait, Springfield hasn't decided to grace us with this pistol yet.

    I'm with stalkingbear on this one, tough choice as both are very well made handguns. I think this might come down to personal preference when you hold them in your hands. The XD will fight smaller hands better.

    Good Luck, and I think you'll be happy with either choice.
  5. spittinfire

    spittinfire Active Member Supporter

    I have no experience with the USP but I do have 2 XDs and love them both. They are simple to use and reliable as a rock. I'd go with the XD!
  6. oldandslow

    oldandslow New Member

    smiter, 2/16/09

    I own an HK USP-compact .45 and have fired a few XD's, though not enough to have an informed opinion on them. I also have a number of other .45's including Beretta, SW 3rd generation, Sigs, and Springer 1911's. The HK's are well known for being reliable, accurate and durable over time. They are also well known for having one of the worst double-action triggers around (long, heavy, and stacks severely before firing), having poor customer service and great difficulty in obtaining aftermarket parts. The prices on the HK's are usually much higher than a comparable quality pistol (Glock, Springfield, SW, etc.) and mags are usually about fifty dollars a piece.

    So while I like my HK USP-.45 compact I think you could do just as well with another brand and avoid paying the price-premium for the HK name brand. Hope this helps.

    best wishes- oldandslow