The VA and Their 3 Questions????

Discussion in 'The Club House' started by markerdown, Jun 18, 2009.

  1. markerdown

    markerdown New Member

    A buddy of mine just got back from the VA hospital. Before he could see the doc, he had to fill out a form and they asked three questions, something like are you depressed, are you angry and do you feel threatened. He was wondering wth is this bs for.

    One guy told him that if answered yes to any of the questions, he would be placed on a threat list or something of that nature.

    I never heard of this before ; has anyone experienced anything like this with the VA recently?....................markerdown
  2. bobbyb13

    bobbyb13 New Member

    Military, disabled Vets, any Vets are looked on as possible extremists now. I think there was a thread on here about this.


    IGETEVEN New Member

    More Veteran BS

    It's BS and all veterans who want up to date happenings concerning the VA and veteran benefits please visit and bookmark this website for future reference. This guy Larry Scott exposes all the BS rumors that circulate around and cause confusion and paranoia.


    Viral email makes astoundingly stupid claim that the VA is trying to take guns away from veterans.

    by Larry Scott, VA Watchdog.Org

    Sometimes I wonder if people just make up this crap: "Hey, Merle. Hold my beer while I hit the keyboard and start a rumor to scare veterans."

    The latest email making the rounds has the VA setting up vets to take away their weapons. Nonsense! Not just nonsense ... an out-and-out lie!

    Here is the basic content of this completely bogus email:

    U.S. Military Vets being disarmed!

    The U.S. Veterans Administration has been instructed by the Department of Homeland Security to ask military vets 3 questions when they come in for any kind of medical check-up or problem. Answering "Yes" to any single question will result in the vet being disarmed by the government.

    The following e-mail was sent to the [blank] by a Vietnam Veteran. His identity is being concealed to prevent reprisals.

    I had a doctors appointment at the local VA clinic yesterday and found something very interesting I would like to pass along.. While going through triage before seeing the doctor, I was asked at the end of the exam, three questions.
    (1. Did I feel stressed?)
    (2. Did I feel threatened?)
    (3. Did I feel like doing harm to someone?)

    The nurse then informed me, if I had answered yes to any of the questions, I would have lost my concealed carry permit as it would have gone into my medical records and the VA would have reported it to Homeland Security.
    I am a Viet Nam vet and 15 year cc permit holder. Looks like they are going after us vets." Be forewarned and be aware. If you are a veteran, you've been warned.

    Let's look at the stupidity here.

    First, there is no "Veterans Administration" ... it is the Department of Veterans' Affairs. This has to tell you something about the intellect of the person who wrote this.

    Second, Homeland Security didn't tell the VA to ask the questions. These are standard questions used in a pre-appointment interview. A nurse usually asks these questions. It is the VA's responsibility to monitor all health issues, including mental health. I have been asked these questions many times. And, I have answered "yes" to the stress question, and still have my weapons and a carry permit.

    Third, the VA doesn't report anything to Homeland Security.

    Fourth, carry permits are issued by states, counties or municipalities ... not Homeland Security. Again ... this person doesn't even know the laws of the land.

    Fifth, there are only two reasons (defined by the Department of Justice) that would allow the VA to report a veteran and get them on the NICS "no buy" list for weapons: 1. The veteran is adjudicated as an incompetent. 2. The veteran is involuntarily committed to a mental institution (including a VA psychiatric ward ... "flight deck").

    Shame on the person who wrote this email.

    Shame on anyone who forwards it.

    And, to anyone who believes it, maybe you should answer "yes" to the question about feeling threatened. :rolleyes:

  4. paganwolf

    paganwolf New Member

    Very Well Said IGE!! I have seen this e-mail $hit and just deleted it. I am used to answering these questions, the first time I was asked by a nurse I was told that alot of vets do not belive in PTSD that it was a way to look for signs. "Twas this and nothing more."
  5. markerdown

    markerdown New Member

    I never saw an email but it sounded like bs to me and this guy was givin me a line. I will confirm this next week when i visit the local VA clinic. I'll play three questions with em' :) markerdown