The Lone Survivor

Discussion in 'The Club House' started by Threetango, May 31, 2014.

  1. Threetango

    Threetango Audentes Fortuna Iuvat Supporter

    4,528
    234
    63
    Somewhat weapons in the media related but mods you can place it elsewhere if you want.
    Wanted to say the Lone Survivor DVD will be available to buy Tuesday June 3rd.
    If you haven't seen it or want a copy to see again it's well worth buying.
     
  2. Sniper03

    Sniper03 Supporting Member Supporter

    7,729
    217
    63
    Seen the Movie at the Theater! It was well worth going and I will also be buying the DVD since I want a copy and want to watch it again. Thanks for the info on the date of release.

    03
     

  3. Axxe55

    Axxe55 The Apocalypse Is Coming.....

    7
    2
    0
    from the reviews i have read so far, i will probably just go ahead and buy it when it hits the stores here.
     
  4. Shoobee

    Shoobee New Member

    2,007
    1
    0
    An ill planned military op that went bad from the get-go. Lots of action but very little plot other than pure incompetence.
     
  5. Pasquanel

    Pasquanel Proud to be an American Supporter

    1,976
    299
    83
    Now thats harsh! So Big Boy you could have killed the kid with a knife? Really?
     
  6. Pasquanel

    Pasquanel Proud to be an American Supporter

    1,976
    299
    83
    You speak like this is only a movie! Like it didn't really happen! Very little plot? Pure incompetence? What in the hell do you know about what really happened here?
     
  7. Axxe55

    Axxe55 The Apocalypse Is Coming.....

    7
    2
    0
    are you really this dense or is it an act you put on when get on the forum?

    you do realize this was based on a real event and not a fictional movie, don't you?
     
  8. SRK97

    SRK97 Well-Known Member Supporter

    3,881
    565
    113
    I highly recommend the book it has a lot of the stuff noy in the movie.
     
  9. Franklin1995

    Franklin1995 New Member

    565
    0
    0
  10. Shoobee

    Shoobee New Member

    2,007
    1
    0
    The whole operation was a blunder. The intelligence was bad from the start.

    The QRF was not standing by or ready.

    Long before they spotted the goat herders, they saw that they were vastly outnumbered by muj. That was the time to call-in an air strike while getting the heck out of there.

    Would I have killed the goat herders? No. But I would have tied them up enough so that their walk home would have taken a long time.

    Watching a CF in the guise of an action movie is not entertaining to me.
     
  11. ShagNasty1001

    ShagNasty1001 New Member

    1,526
    0
    0

    And you know all of this.....how? It's their job to be in areas where they're outnumbered..


    America doesn't need a Marine Corps, they want one
     
  12. Shoobee

    Shoobee New Member

    2,007
    1
    0
    I've explained to you what went wrong and what they should have done such that all 4 would have lived to fight another day. Instead, it was a CF.
     
  13. Axxe55

    Axxe55 The Apocalypse Is Coming.....

    7
    2
    0
    Shoobee, if you really were in the military, then you would know that soldiers don't get to pick and choose which orders, missions or operations they decide to follow or accept.

    even if the intelligence were bad, that isn't the fault of the soldiers on the ground. they went in and did the job that they tasked to do.

    simple and sad fact is, soldiers do die sometimes on missions. and here you are, trying to malign the honor of these men, with some of the same nonsense you spout all the time. you are sorry excuse of an American and even sorrier excuse for a human being.
     
  14. DrFootball

    DrFootball disappointed & disgusted, But DETERMINED... Lifetime Supporter

    8,039
    0
    0
    Shoobee, I suggest you write to Petty Officer Lutrell and tell him how you feel. Or better, just mosy on over the UDT in San Diego and tell that to the Instructors Cadre there,..
    One thing I will say about the few Frogs I have met, aside from not talking much, is they don't like folks who "Weren't there " talking to them about it. So you go right ahead there with that.
    I'd be interested to hear what you'd say to someone who was on the Ground at Desert One...


    Sent from my iPhone using Firearms Talk
     
  15. ShagNasty1001

    ShagNasty1001 New Member

    1,526
    0
    0

    Nobody had any idea what was going to happen when they got there. They did what they were supposed to, complete the mission.. If you've ever dealt with radios and comms, you'd understand that things go wrong and especially around mountains, signals are sketchy and they knew that.. Not their fault, it's the nature of the beast. Nobody knows what went right or wrong there except Petty Officer Lutrell and the three who gave their lives to protect their brothers in arms. So quit talking like you know what happened when you don't..


    America doesn't need a Marine Corps, they want one
     
  16. Steel_Talon

    Steel_Talon New Member

    1,766
    0
    0
    READ Lutrell's BOOK.... For a closer to reality account of the battle. The movie adds to the "Hollywood prose" of the story Where as the book informs the truer account and actions of the team (as allowed by Naval Intel review of opp-sec issues)
     
  17. Steel_Talon

    Steel_Talon New Member

    1,766
    0
    0
    I honor these 4 men who fought that fight. They were given the short end of the stick, and they laid waste to many enemy fighters before they themselves could fight no more. Bushido!

    Ya know gents. When it comes to the fight of battle, no matter how hard you analyze, predict, train, and seek to control outcome. Those who have been where the bad things happen know that the FIGHT is of itself entirely. IT goes and develops the way IT wants to. We react "within it" with our training, firepower, courage ,wit and a whole lotta luck. So lets not cast dispersions/and discredit upon those who fought and there mission. Let us accept (as they did) that it was necessary for them to be there at that time.

    Same blood ,Different mud
     
  18. ctshooter

    ctshooter New Member

    1,159
    2
    0
    ImageUploadedByFirearms Talk1401658310.868640.jpg

    Reguardless of your stance and or opinion let them rest in peace.
     
  19. DrFootball

    DrFootball disappointed & disgusted, But DETERMINED... Lifetime Supporter

    8,039
    0
    0

    Excellent Book! I read it on my Bermuda Cruise Trip in Nov. of 2011. S_T is Correct. Only Petty Officer Lutrell and those who did not return know what happen. Anyone who was not there, has no business calling the Op a "CF" And CT is also "Correct" Lets let the men who did not return from Operation Redwing RIP as Fallen Brothers are Supposed to be....

    Unless Shoobee is in the ROTC and Needs a Paper to write....In that Case Shoobee, since I taught ROTC & JrROTC for over a decade after my Discharge, write me with the Parameters of your assignment and i'll be glad to read for you. If not,..lets leave those Seals Rest In Peace...
    If you need to read more of accounts of Seals work,..You want to read Dr. Howard Wasdin's Book( was a Seal Sniper In Somalia before becoming a Chiropractor), or Chuck Faraar's Book,.


    Note: Shoobee's Bio States he was Marine Arty, so I will give him a "partial Pass" here,..

    Shoobee: Having Been an Army WO, I can't attest to the fact of how difficult it is to go through BUDS, but I have attended & Passed Sections I & II of "The Benning School for Wayward Youth", and I can tell you that at the age of 19 heading for 20, It darn near Killed me(Ranger School),..So I can only Imagine, and go on what Petty Officer Lutrell wrote about BUDS in his Book, My copy of which he graciously Autographed for me when I met him at an Special Operations Warrior Foundation event. His Book sits in a honored place on my "Memorial Mantle Wall" next to Gen. Hal Moore's Book, and Col. R.K. Brown's Book, and my Fathers Korean War Diary notes. I'm sure 200 folks would have reacted 200 other ways then Petty Officer Lutrell did,...


    Sent from my iPad using Firearms Talk
     
    Last edited: Jun 1, 2014
  20. robocop10mm

    robocop10mm Lifetime Supporting Member Lifetime Supporter

    11,380
    2
    0
    More trolling by one of our resident trolls.