This is an old thread, but if the OPer is still around, check out Acme Sports in Seymour, right off I-65. Very fair, personable, Class III and a lot of tactical doodads.Hi-Tek in Sellersburg is a good place. They're a family-owned and operated gun shop in Sellersburg that I've been dealing with for 2 or 3 years. They do basic gunsmithing, repacing sights, painting, etc.
HiTEK Firearms & Training
123 S. Indiana Ave.
Sellersburg, IN 47172
812-246-4664