Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'Hunting Forum' started by Georgiahunter, Aug 27, 2011.
What kind of shot do you prefer? For me it's double lung.
well, i use 350grn .458 caliber bullets around 1600-2100 fps depending on whether im using the socom or winchester model 70. pretty much anywhere does the trick, but i prefer heart/lung shots since it doesnt ruin much meat.
Head shots...they drop on the spot !
Neck shots drop them on the spot to and easier to hit
I prefer the Heart Lung shot. Obviously a head shot works quickly also if properly placed. I do not want any animal I shoot to suffer long at all. I am a hunter but my ultimate goal is being as humane as possible. Even on the coyotes I shoot. If I am going to kill anything I want it to come quick.
I don't keep trophies, I eat 'em. Whatever shot that will work well and I'm not tracking. I really like the 9.3x57, it takes the edge off some shots. It will plow through like a frieght train at 150 yards or less. A 286gr partition or 285gr cast lead GC at 2100fps does it every time.
Not a hunter yet, but interested in moving that direction...
Neck shots. Assuming you are still talking lateral and not severing the spine, isn't that a less humane way to go? Unless you are lucky to get the arteries on either side or the spine, isn't that shot, incapacitating though it might be, a slower way to kill?
I would think lateral shot to the shoulder blade going through the lungs/heart would be the best shot. I'm just talking, not arguing.
I agree with Chris. I only believe in taking high percentage shots no matter what you're shooting at. A neck shot will be an instant kill if you are good enough to shoot it's spinal cord. However, if you fail to hit the exact spot you have a deer with a muscle wound that will run and suffer. Just my .02.
Dad always taught us to shoot for the neck. If they don't drop instantly, which is the best case scenario, they only make it 20 meters or so. Thank the animal for its life and its a good day of hunting.
Chest is your best bet, bigger target than head or neck, less movement involved,margin for error is better. Getting fancy is for suckers, or someone without respect for the critter on the other end. Don't forget that hunting dosn't offer the lab like conditions of the range. Be willling to pass on the shot if conditions aren't right.
Welcome, firecaptain! You should go on over to the introductions thread and tell us a little about yourself.
it depends on my mood, if I'm hunting just for the food what ever I can get head or chest cavity. If I'm going for meet and horns (I sometimes make things out of them beeds, toggles...etc) I try for the chest cavity but sometimes it doesn't work out that way.
Where at in the chest cavaty is the heart/lungs on a dear? Is it right "above" their sternum between their legs like a dogs?
Interesting thread. I have been hunting elk and deer since I was 12.I hunted along with my dad before I reached 12 and could get my legal permit that is. This was 1970. I have killed a lot of deer and elk a few bear and moose also in the 41 years.
I have taken head neck heart and lung shots.I have used 30-30, 30-06 ,7mm mag , 300 winchester mag.But my go to rifle is a model 600 remington 350 magnum my dad gave me when I was 14.
I hunt the heavy alder brush almost exclusively so I can assure to get my elk every year. I always pick off a deer comming and going some time during the season for sausauge.There are two things you never ever do hunting elk and deer and that is gut shoot or shoulder shoot a animal.Both rate as stupidity in its most blatant form.
It is a very cruel painful way for a animal to die and they can cover a lot of ground on three leggs or gut shot to and in rough terrian like the bitteroots in northern Idaho where i grew up and hunt. they can get away from you.
I have seen a elk shot heart and lung by a 458 winchester magnum a school teacher bought who was from south dakota and convinced him self he needed a elephant rifle to kill elk.
He recruted three of my friends and me at age 16 to help him quarter the elk and pack it out.The 458 whent through the chest cavity from a profile shot and exploded the lungs and heart.It hit with such force it blood shot both front quarters and the back strap so bad most could not be saved.
Shooting a deer with a 458 winchester mag would pretty much render the meat all usless.
Shooting a deer or elk in the neck usualy takes out a whole vertabrae and they fall on the spot and bleed out. It does not kill them. They are in shock and have no feeling becuase there spinal cord is severed. They live about three or four minutes.I dont waste a bullet because the heart pumps the blood out fast because any hit in the neck tears up the arteries and they lose there blood in a gush. I have never took a neck shot that animal went one step.
A head shot turns there lights off instantly dead on impact. A heart and lung shot always makes them spasm as the shock wave travels through there body.This takes about a second or less and then they all run down hill about 100 yards and crumple up dead.
I have never shot a animal in the chest except a bear from the front.It is not a shot that presents itself very often and the bullet often travels on in and blows the stomache open sending bile and stomache acids all over the chest cavity just like a gut shot and ruins meat and is a mess to clean up in the woods so it dont rot the meat.
The neck is the easiest shot any way.
My rifle is desighned for the brush and to take down larger animals than white tails.I have heart and lunged white tails with it in more open terrian out at a couple hundred yards and I take a heart and lung at that range. I use remington factory corlokt ammo in 200 grain.It goes through a deer and does not blood shot more than a area of the ribs about six inches arround.
On a elk it always gets caught under the hide and I cut out a quarter size mushroomed bullet.
But on a whilte tail up close like 50 yards or so it blood shots them pretty bad in a heart and lung.So I always neck shoot dear also.A 7mm mag or 300 mag just destroys the meat with massive blood shot. The faster the bullet the worse it will blood shot.A 30-06 is actualy the perfect round for both deer and elk moose or bear. But it is not as good in the brush as a 350 magnum so I pack the old 350.
At close range like brush hunting is a 30-30 works fine on both deer and elk but is a little lighter than I like for a bear although many people kill black bear with them every year.
The heart and lung shot is right behind ther front shoulder. Not through the front shoulder that blows hell out of the meat and when it contacts bone sends a massive wave through the animal and blood shots the whole front shoulder and usualy the back strap.
My brother in law once shot a white tail accidently because he out right missed in the shoulder with a 444 marlin from about 30 yards and it ruined both front quarters and all the back strap.How ever he said it did not go any where.It fell over in the dirt road he shot it off.
Head shots are hard to get and some times so are a heart and lung. But that neck can always be shot at from any angle comming at you running away profiling and it makes them bleed out and you dont have to go looking for them.
Onenut: That was a very well written & thought out post. Kudos.
right behind the front legs lungs, heart, liver, spin...etc. I've learned when you shoot a deer with a 7mm mag or 30-30 in the chest there pretty much done for they might run a little but the past six I've taken either just dropped or ran for about 75-100 yards and died.
Seen and shot many "neck shot" white tail, every one of them dropped like a stone.
I prefer the neck shot for this reason, instant kill, but I will also take the vitals if the animal is moving or the distance is beyond 150 yards.
Thanks arms master.I just added my two cents to the stack of posts on the issue
neck -vs- heart /lung
I lean toward heart / lung only because of some personal experience. 1. My dad tought me that way. 2. As a medic I've learned that death from a gunshot comes through hydraulic failure.
On point two, classroom learning about anatomy and physiology the chest cavity provides the largest surface for any structural compromise. Real life has taught me that people perform very similar to gunshot wounds as deer. Some die very quickly some , not so much. I've seen people and deer die very quickly from head shots neck shots and chest shots. I've had the oppertunity to talk with a young woman who was shot in the neck by her boyfriend. Her spinal cord was severed and she could not feel her body other than a severe burning sensation neck down. She lives to this day. I've talked with and treated patients with gunshot wounds to the chest, usually handguns. The ones that tend to live are hit single lung and limited vascular damage and get to surgery quickly.
I personaly worry that if I shoot a deer in the neck, sure he goes down quick, but there is a good chance he will watch me walk up, take a few high fives with my friends, some photos, and commence to field dress all while trapped in his head and very much alive.
I also keep my shots in the heart/lung area no matter the yardage. I have killed deer from 20 feet to just shy of 400 yards . Allways tried to use the best bullet for the job, no sp or corelocks. Never shot for the head/neck after seeing some deer with jaws blowed off and rotting neck wounds. Make a good shot or don't shot at all. Thats may view of 40 years of deer hunting.