Recoil in a 12ga vs. 20ga

Discussion in 'General Shotgun Discussion' started by PeteZaHut, Oct 14, 2010.

  1. PeteZaHut

    PeteZaHut New Member

    132
    0
    0
    I am planning on eventually getting a semi-auto shotgun for home defense once I am out of school. A 12ga is the only type of shotgun I have ever shot. I found it pretty powerful and it took me significant time to line up the next shot due to the recoil of the first shot. I was wondering how much less powerful a 20ga is. Is it something you can get fairly rapid shots off with on a semi-auto shotgun?
     
  2. orangello

    orangello New Member

    19,156
    0
    0
    I don't know how to compare the two different guages, but a smart person will be along for that shortly i'd bet.

    I have seen some "reduced recoil" buckshot for 12's before though; maybe that would do the trick. I haven't tried it myself; i don't use my shotty enough. :( Poor ole mossy needs more playtime.

    http://www.midwayusa.com/viewProduct/?productNumber=482134 Here are some reviews on one brand; it appears to run better in the pump shotguns, no surprise.
     
    Last edited: Oct 14, 2010

  3. Uncle Tom

    Uncle Tom New Member

    36
    0
    0
    12 vs 20 for SD

    Check in at CHUCKHAWKS.COM: Guns and Shooting Online; Motorcycles and Riding; Military History; Astronomy and Photography Online; Travel and Fishing Information Guide for some discussion from an expert on SD shotguns. He tends to favor the 20 gauge pump with short (18=20") barrel for indoor HD use. As to recoil, think gun weight and action more than gauge. By action I mean fixed breech guns (pump, o/u) have more felt recoil than automatics. Rubber recoil pads DO help. Also think about ammunition -- he favors buckshot, but others argue for slugs or bird shot.
     
  4. MoHawk

    MoHawk New Member

    2,429
    0
    0
    I am no expert either, but the 20g I fired seemed to have a lot less recoil. Regardless, why do you need to fire mulitple shots quickly? I have a 12g for home defense and cannot see why I'd need to quickly fire off a lot of rounds, unless my house was being attacked by Zombies. Then I would need to FOR SURE
     
  5. diggsbakes

    diggsbakes New Member

    1,680
    0
    0
    In my opinion:

    For self-defense pump action is plenty fast. If you shoot your home/personal defense SG enough as you should in order to safely rely on it to protect your home, racking the gun becomes second nature and can be used in conjunction with the recoiling SG to cycle smoothly, recover, and engage your next (because your first target shouldn't need a follow-up) target.

    Semi-Auto shot guns are very useful in shooting sports. i.e. trap, skeet, sporting clays.

    One exception would be if (and you may be) this question is in reference towards a Saiga. If you have one great, use it, but if you are considering one for a home defense SG, look around. For what you'll pay for a Saiga, you can get quite a package (maybe close to 2) for a Winchester 1200, 1300 or 1400, Mossberg 500 or 590, Remington 870 and much more and they eat EVERYTHING!!! Plus modification is a blast!
     
  6. orangello

    orangello New Member

    19,156
    0
    0
    I would think there would be a better selection of ammo for the 12, especially if things go from bad to worse.
     
  7. Esteban

    Esteban New Member

    74
    0
    0
    I use Winchester reduced recoil in my pistol grip pump & it is much better than standard loads.
     
  8. Missileman

    Missileman New Member

    491
    0
    0
    The recoil is totally dependent on 1: The weight of the gun, 2: The weight of the load (oz of shot) and 3: the velocity of the load (fps). There are many 20ga loads that equal 12 ga loads (example, 1 oz loads are typical for both 12 and 20ga) and with an equal weight/action gun they would recoil the same. A gas operated semi-auto will recoil less than a pump of the same weight as some of the propellant gasses are bled off for the action. There are lighter weight 20 ga loads available, but for self defense almost all are maximum load rounds and will recoil as hard as any 20ga rounds will, and close to what the 12ga recoils. Sometimes the 20 ga will even feel harder as some of the guns are built lighter than their 12ga equals. Bottom line, for self defense the recoil will be similar, but for hunting or target shooting you can use reduced loads (in both the 12 and 20) for less recoil.
     
  9. orangello

    orangello New Member

    19,156
    0
    0
  10. tonydewar

    tonydewar New Member

    619
    0
    0
    recoil

    yes i do a bumpbuster but i shoot 500 to 1000 rounds a month a sd gun does not need it if you ever have to use it you will will more than likely be shooting offhand
     
  11. pranc2

    pranc2 New Member

    216
    0
    0
    20 gauge is quite a bit less than 12. never shot buck out of a 20ga but did fire some triple aut buck in a 12ga that kicked something fierce.

    i have been thinking about getting a shotgun for a while and have had the same problem deciding between the two. im leaning towards the 20ga mostly because of utility. i have a .45 auto for home defense so it wouldnt be for that. :D
     
  12. tonydewar

    tonydewar New Member

    619
    0
    0
    12 vs 20

    the 12 with a 28-30 in bbl is the all around gun what will it be used for most ?hunting ? clay games?weight chokes and barrels from one extreem to the other one shotgun only? need to try for a compromise