Need to Match a Revolver to a Rifle

Discussion in 'Revolver Handguns' started by Dillinger, Aug 1, 2010.

  1. Dillinger

    Dillinger New Member

    Okay, so I have this sweet Winchester lever action that my grandfather left me when he past on ( RIP RC ). :(

    I believe it's an 1873, it's chambered in .44 wcf ( .44-40 ) and this rifle has killed so many deer in it's day, I am pretty sure the Deer Coalition of the Upper Peninsula have an open bounty on the owner. :)

    I am thinking about getting a pistol that will "match" the era/style of this historic firearm and would like it to be chambered in the same caliber ( for obvious reasons ).

    I really like the Schofield, and I know that Uberti makes replica pistols that are "like" the S&W number 3 and chambered in .44-40. I don't need a true "era" piece, as this weapon will be fired and be part of a set that I would consider to be functional.

    That said, I don't want a modern looking pistol made of titanium and looks like it belongs in the hands of some wannabe Cowboy Gansta from the Los Zetas hierarchy. :rolleyes:

    So, revolver guys, what do you think and what are your thoughts??

    Price - I am open, but don't need a $10K authentic piece either.
    Timing - Probably late this year, first part of 2011
    Color - Brushed stainless to match the rifle
    Caliber - .44-40

    And I do have a line on some gun leather to carry it in, but obviously I would like to have the pistol first since I will be getting the holster cut to match.

    Thanks for the input!!

  2. Dzscubie

    Dzscubie New Member


    I was looking at Uberti single actions today as I have a 7 1/2" in 357 that I'm going to sell to get another Ruger to have a matched set for Cowboy Action Shooting.

    Go to and look for the below Uberti. They have several chambered in 44-40.

    Uberti 1873 Cattleman 44/40 5 1/2” New buy it now $519.00


  3. Franciscomv

    Franciscomv New Member

    Schofields are, IMHO, the best looking revolvers ever made. Uberti makes one but as far as I know it's not available in stainless, the only models in .44-40 are blued. The Cattleman does come with a matte stainless finish in .44-40, though.

    Or, like Cane would say, you can get a Colt. The 1873 Single Action Army is made in .44-40, in several barrel lengths and two finishes (blued and nickel). Change the ugly factory plastic grips for some nice wood and you've got a beautiful American classic.

    Ruger made a .44-40 Vaquero in stainless a while back, maybe you can get a hold of one of those. It's a pitty that they don't make a .44-40 Blackhawk.
  4. BillM

    BillM Active Member Supporter

  5. Jpyle

    Jpyle New Member

    Ditto to what Francisco says...go with the Peacemaker, it's the 1873 Winchester's natural companion.
  6. NGIB

    NGIB New Member

    Jeez JD, just get a Glock in .40, spray paint it silver, and rechamber your rifle. Why you gotta make everything so difficult? :D
  7. Jo da Plumbr

    Jo da Plumbr New Member

    Come on guys

    Stop all the jibber jabber and post up some pics.:mad:

    At least links.
  8. freefall

    freefall New Member

    Used to see ads in the Shotgun News for an 1875 Remington replica from EMF. Came in .44-40, .45Colt, and .357. I always thought they looked kind of nice. A little different anyway. Everybody at the SASS matches has a Colt or clone.
  9. Clem

    Clem Member

    There are a number of clones available in 44-40 in S&W, Colt or Remington configurations. You can have a lot of fun looking at the details and making a decision.

    The only thing I would recommend for your consideration is that if you want to shoot the gun, don’t shoot it much and use black powder equivalent loads. If it was made before the turn of the 20th century it is made of softer steel than the guns made after about 1895. If you want to pump out ammo with a ’73 and an appropriate handgun, consider getting a ’73 clone rifle as well and saving an irreplaceable piece of history.
  10. superc

    superc Member

    Back in the day, there were two different 44/40 loads. One for rifle and a weaker one for pistols. As someone noted, if your rifle is an original, it is a black powder rifle. Caution should therefore be used when selecting ammo for it. Amusingly enough, your new manufacture 44/40 pistol, being made in the smokeless powder era, may now be the stronger of the two weapons.
  11. steve666

    steve666 New Member

    I'd still pick one of the Uberti S&W clones, they look great and shoot great: