Mathews LX Compound bow vs. Martin Jaguar recurve

Discussion in 'Range Report' started by amoroque, Jul 30, 2010.

  1. amoroque

    amoroque New Member

    1,229
    0
    0
    For this range report I wanted to compare the penetration of a compound bow vs. the recurve.
    I purchased a new target so that if I hit any worn or damaged areas on the target it wouldnt give me a false reading.
    I have shot the Mathews LX compound for almost 4 years now and absolutely love this bow. It has almost become an extension of my arm.
    Yesterday was the first day I shot the Martin Jaguar, however, it seems to be a great bow. It is very different from the compound in that it has no sights.....almost like shooting from the hip with a pistol. My shooting buddy also enjoyed shooting the bow. He has a bigger draw length than i do, so I believe the Martin Jaguar would be a good choice for all archers capable of a 50lb draw.
     
    Last edited: Jul 30, 2010
  2. amoroque

    amoroque New Member

    1,229
    0
    0
    This first picture is of the new target. For the purpose of this test, the target was positioned at 20 yards.
     

    Attached Files:


  3. amoroque

    amoroque New Member

    1,229
    0
    0
    This is showing the length of the arrows. I used all of the same Easton arrows with the same fletchings, points and nocks.
     

    Attached Files:

  4. amoroque

    amoroque New Member

    1,229
    0
    0
    First up I shot the Mathews at the target. Please excuse the bad grouping and the beer belly. LOL
     

    Attached Files:

  5. amoroque

    amoroque New Member

    1,229
    0
    0
    As you can see from the meaurements below the compound penetrated the target at approximately 13 inches.
     

    Attached Files:

  6. amoroque

    amoroque New Member

    1,229
    0
    0
    Next up was the Martin. I used the same arrows and the same distance. Being the first time I shot this bow, I was not exactly dialed in, however, I was very happy to hit the target with all 3 shots.
     

    Attached Files:

  7. amoroque

    amoroque New Member

    1,229
    0
    0
    As you can see from the pictures below the penetration of the recurve was approxiomately 7.25 to 7.5 inches.
     

    Attached Files:

  8. amoroque

    amoroque New Member

    1,229
    0
    0
    20 yard conclusion:

    By no means do I feel that I am or would be comfortable using this bow (recurve) for hunting at this point. I feel that hunting with this would require lots of practice, at varying distances. I have always had pride in knowing that I would not shoot an animal with firearm or bow without knowing it would result in an instant and humane kill.

    The Mathews has been field tested and the Mathews bow will deliver a force that would send an arrow entirely through an Elk or Mule Deer.

    The Martin Jaguar has less penetrating power, however, at 20 yards I feel that it does have enough penetrating power to kill a big game animal such as a whitetail deer, mule deer or elk at 20 yards. Given that the density of this target is much greater than that of an animal, even a penetration of a big game animal at 7 inches would definitely impact vital organs (heart and lungs) and result in a kill.

    I would also like to test this on 30 and 40 yard increments in the near future. More to come!
     
  9. Dillinger

    Dillinger New Member

    23,972
    2
    0
    Really excellent report, and I believe this is the first of a bow.

    Thank you for taking the time to write up and show us the results.

    +1 :)

    JD
     
  10. stalkingbear

    stalkingbear Well-Known Member

    4,099
    40
    48
    Excellent test! I shoot a Mathews Switchback XT due to my bad shoulders. I'm sure you'll learn to shoot instinctive as you practice. I want to make my own longbow from scratch someday.
     
  11. hunter Joe

    hunter Joe New Member

    2,361
    1
    0
    I was going to go primitive a few years back. Bought some cedar shafts and fletched my own arrows, dug out the old recurved bow and finger tabs and couldn't get the dang arrows to stick in the target at 30 yards.

    The arrows didn't go to waste as I gave them to a boy scout leader a couple months back for some kind of award ceremony. The troop sent me a picture with their arrow awards and that put an extremely large smile on my lips.
     
  12. amoroque

    amoroque New Member

    1,229
    0
    0
    Thanks for the kind words guys, I really appreciate it.
    Hopefully I'll get to the range soon and be able to post more information.
     
  13. Txhillbilly

    Txhillbilly Well-Known Member

    4,443
    42
    48
    Great report. I wanted to get back into archery,but my joints can't take it anymore.I punished my body too much when I was young,and I'm paying for it now.
     
  14. NGIB

    NGIB New Member

    7,143
    1
    0
    Very nifty addition to our range report area. The bow I shot today (RazorX) is a long (43" ATA, 8" BH) bow that is different from today's short compounds. When I get to where I can hit a target with any kind of regularity, I believe I'll post some stuff like this...