Homeowner pursues suspected thief, shoots him

Discussion in 'The Club House' started by sculker, Apr 27, 2008.

  1. sculker

    sculker New Member

    Homeowner pursues suspected thief, shoots himby Brent Whiting - Apr. 25, 2008 11:46 AM
    The Arizona Republic
    Police are sorting out a shooting that took place early Friday in northwest Phoenix, resulting in the wounding of a suspected auto burglar and the closing of 43rd Avenue south of Bell Road.

    The injured man, who suffered wounds that were not life-threatening, was shot by an irate homeowner who told officers he gave chase and fired after somebody tried to break into his vehicle, police said.

    There were no immediate arrests as investigators gathered evidence and tried to determine whether the shooter, under the facts of the case, was justified in using deadly force, said Detective Stacie Derge, a Phoenix police spokeswoman.
    "Nobody is in custody," Derge said. "We have a lot of investigation to do. We will look at the circumstances of the whole situation and determine what charges will be filed."

    Neither the shooter nor the wounded man was identified.

    According to Derge, the incident began shortly before 5 a.m. outside a home in the 18600 block of North 31st Drive, northwest of Union Hills Drive and Interstate 17.

    The homeowner told police that his car alarm sounded and he stepped outside to see what was happening. He said somebody tried to break into his car and he saw a man walking away from the vehicle.

    The suspected auto burglar stepped into a pickup truck and drove away, while the homeowner got into his vehicle, a Pontiac, and gave chase, following the man through surrounding neighborhoods.

    Eventually, police said, they ended up on 43rd Avenue south of Bell Road, where the homeowner fired several rounds into the pickup truck, wounding the driver at least twice.

    Both the wounded man and the homeowner drove home. A female passenger in the pickup truck escaped unharmed.

    When the wounded man arrived home, family members drove him to a hospital for treatment. The homeowner, who also had a passenger in his vehicle, was contacted by police at his residence.

    Police closed 43rd Avenue between Bell Road and Paradise Lane as officers processed evidence, including car parts and shell casings scattered in the southbound lanes of the roadway.

    In general, Arizona allows the use of physical and deadly force if a "reasonable person" believes it is immediately necessary to prevent crimes such as arson, burglary, kidnapping and all forms of murder and sex crimes.

    Under a measure that Gov. Janet Napolitano signed into law in April 2006, people are justified in using deadly physical force if they reasonably believe their life or the life of another is in danger.

    In the event charges are brought in such a case, prosecutors must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that a defendant claiming self-defense had acted without justification.


    I think he should have called the police. He could have got his plate number. Would you get by with this in your state?
  2. hillbilly68

    hillbilly68 New Member

    This is what the anti's believe all of us will do if given the chance. Guy was out of line, would like to know his background. It is so stupid to chase down someone that tried to break in to a vehicle and doubly stupid to start shooting at them during the chase.

  3. bellx1

    bellx1 Guest

    the shooter certianly wouldn't be able to get away with this in Cali. he was out of line, and endangered others by firing from one moving vehicle to another on a public road. he shouldv'e called the police.
  4. bkt

    bkt New Member

    Bring a handgun and a camera. Shoot with a camera: get the guy, his companions and the tag number of the truck. His companion should have been on the phone with the cops as they started their pursuit.

    There's no way the homeowner would have gotten away with this in New York.
  5. Dillinger

    Dillinger New Member

    This guy was out of line and would definitely be charged here in Wash. State. Shooting at a vehicle, on a public street, with another person in the cab of the truck. Looks bad all around. No doubt they will play the rage defense in court and maybe he walks with time served, but he isn't getting out of this scott-free. It would be the wild friggin west down there if they don't do something to send a message.

  6. RL357Mag

    RL357Mag New Member

    When I received my CCW permit the issuing officer clearly stated that I was not allowed to even shoot someone who broke into my house at 3 a.m.! He said, and I quote " I could, but I would have a lot of paper work to fill out!" I almost extended a 3 am invitation to him... In NY you cannot use deadly force to protect property - only your life. I believe that idiot cop was wrong about someone breaking into my house, especially if the perpetrator is armed, and he would be by the time the cops showed up! I would never consider chasing someone down , and I think that guy in Arizona will at least have his license revoked. Even Sheriff Joe Arpaio wouldn't let that pass. I wish he would run for President!
  7. rwsnc

    rwsnc New Member

    Clearly he wasn't acting in self defense, if he was chasing the thief. Might be some jail time in his future.