Firearms Talk banner
1 - 18 of 18 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
209 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I'm buying one of these but don't know which. I keep bouncing back and forth. I love 1911's and the history but am leaning towards the XD. I'm sure ill be happy with either. I plan on carrying whatever I get.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,292 Posts
A 40 caliber in a subcompact polymer frame is not my idea of a good time. Sharp, snappy recoil and a lot of muzzle flip.

Are you planning on carrying either of these? If so, the XD would be my vote. If its a fun gun or range gun, then the 1911 gets the nod.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,292 Posts
JustinM said:
Well this is about the least helpful thread I have posted lol. I was hoping to get people's thoughts on the guns, not the companies that make them. If you have an XD of any kind or a High Standard 1911 feedback on them would be great. I appreciate the participation but its really not helping my decision. I'm leaning towards the XD40 to carry.
Both are good guns. You just didn't provide any info on how the gun would be used. If its CCW, then go with the XD. If its anything else, go with the High Standard.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
2,562 Posts
I recently bought a Ruger SR40 - love that gun, not the snappy recoil many 40's have. I am seriously considering getting a SR40-C as a carry option.

This is just me, but I think 1911's are great looking guns, solid feeling, all of that. But they have limited magazine capacity** and I personally don't care for double-action pistols. Plus, the market is absolutely flooded with these things and the fact that everybody has to have one, makes me not want one lol.

**I have seen a lot of comments from folks on this site such as "if you can't get it done with a couple shots of .45 acp, you probably aren't gonna get it done". What the hell ever. My expectation is, if I need to resort to draw and fire, things are terribly wrong and probably confused. If I can put 15 rounds of .40 S&W on a target or MULTIPLE targets, versus 8 rounds of .45 acp? I'll take volume over the stopping power of just one bullet (stopping power ballistics on these two rounds are very similar)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,292 Posts
chloeshooter said:
This is just me, but I think 1911's are great looking guns, solid feeling, all of that. But they have limited magazine capacity** and I personally don't care for double-action pistols.
You mean single-action, right?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
821 Posts
What will you use the gun for? Carry, target shooting, home protection...or a combo of all 3?

For carry, go with the XD40

For the latter 2, go with a nice 1911.

This is just my $.02 on which one to buy depending on the purpose for it.....but to clear up the 1911 SA/DA myth its ALWAYS a SA trigger on a 1911, not a double action. The trigger has one function, not two, despite dropping the hammer. The trigger wont do anything until you rack the slide/lower the hammer.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,292 Posts
StainlessSteel215 said:
....but to clear up the 1911 SA/DA myth its ALWAYS a SA trigger on a 1911, not a double action. The trigger has one function, not two, despite dropping the hammer. The trigger wont do anything until you rack the slide/lower the hammer.
A gave the guy a second chance, but apparently it was too subtle. Thanks for clearing up more misinformation in this thread. I just didnt have it in me.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,292 Posts
chloeshooter said:
My SR40 is a single action
That's not entirely true either. The striker on the SR models is only kept partially cocked as the slide is racked, but not fully cocked. The striker is fully cocked and then released as the trigger is pulled. So technically, the trigger on the SR guns leans more toward DAO (double action only) since the trigger is performing two functions with each pull, partially cocking the striker and also releasing the sear.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
2,562 Posts
That's not entirely true either. The striker on the SR models is only kept partially cocked as the slide is racked, but not fully cocked. The striker is fully cocked and then released as the trigger is pulled. So technically, the trigger on the SR guns leans more toward DAO (double action only) since the trigger is performing two functions with each pull, partially cocking the striker and also releasing the sear.
well, Ruger calls it a single action, perhaps they could use your help lol
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,292 Posts
It's all about marketing. I guess if you want to completely technical, the SRs use what's called a preset trigger. Not a true SA and not a true DA.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
209 Posts
Discussion Starter · #17 ·
Olympus said:
Both are good guns. You just didn't provide any info on how the gun would be used. If its CCW, then go with the XD. If its anything else, go with the High Standard.
I literally said I plan on carrying lol. You didn't read.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,627 Posts
no, I don't care for double-action (which the 1911 design very much is). My SR40 is a single action
Ya got that backward. The SR series of handguns have a very short pull double action trigger, seeming much more like a single action than typical DAO and 1911s have true single action triggers.
 
1 - 18 of 18 Posts
Top