Firearms Talk banner
1 - 20 of 32 Posts
G

·
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Have New G17L and G24 (3rd Gen) and I WILL RELOAD FOR THEM BOTH!!! Please Straight Facts and or Information, I Don't Want your OPINION: 2007/2008 Facts And Information!!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,861 Posts
What does your owner's manual say about it? As long as you're loading every round to SAAMI specified pressures, I don't see why there would be an issue. SAAMI spec 9x19 Parabellum pressure is 35 kPSI.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
644 Posts
You Can...just understand the (potential) risks.

I am not aware of any concern over properly reloaded ammunition with jacketed bullets. The concern is lead bullets.

The polygonal rifling of the Glock barrel can cause an greater degree of leading when not using jacketed bullets. Some schools of thought say that this increased leading could potentially cause a pressure spike, even with properly loaded ammunition and result in a kB. Concerns about poor case support in OEM Glock barrels increases the risk if you do experience a pressure spike from barrel leading (although most of the case support issues I know of are .40 calibers).

Some say lead is fine as long as you use hardcast manufactured bullets, and not soft homemade lead bullets. Others say lead is fine as long as you clean the barrel regularly after shooting sessions. And still others discount the concern over barrel leading and pressure spikes completely.

So one side of the argument says don't do it unless you buy an aftermarket barrel with traditional lans/grooves. The other side of the argument says shoot what you want. Glock itself doesn't weigh in except with the standard legalize, "The use of reloaded ammunition will void the Glock warranty, due to the unpredictability of the standards (SAMI/NATO) adhered to, since reloads of poor quality ammunition may not meet (SAMI/NATO) specifications, may exceed limits, and therefore may be unsafe."

I personally think there must be something to the concern, but I am not overly alarmist. I would probably be comfortable shooting hardcast lead bullets at standard pressures and cleaning my barrel at regular intervals.

Or course, what YOU do is a question you have to answer.

At Midway USA 500-count Remington 115 grain FMJ 9mm bullets cost about $55, and 500-count Hunters Supply Hard Cast 115 grain 9mm lead bullets cost about $45. I would probably pay the extra ten bucks with all others things being equal, and not worry about the kB risk. I don't personally reload so if this isn't as easy as buying the different bullets, then ignore my ignorance.

If my post doesn't meet your 2007/2008 facts/information only, then sorry. This issue significantly predates 2007/2008 and there has been no change in the technology of polygonal barrels or lead bullets. I had no luck finding brand new information while researching this topic, so I figured a recap of the known potential issues would be appropriate for other reading the post.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
962 Posts
the manual that came with mine said DO NOT USE RELOADED AMMOin GLOCK factory barrels, so i never did it also says dont use lead ammo, so i didnt. i know you dont want opinions but heres mine anyways, dont go against what they say as it could be dangerous to your safety and the people around you. so make your own call on this one. no one here can give you facts on the subject better than the people at GLOCK. good luck in your search for knowledge though :)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
85 Posts
It's all about quality control, if you are doing your own reloads and can be on top of the process, the quality of your powder and brass, etc you should have no issues just like the huge numbers of shooters who reload for themselves to save money or for accuracy.

The problems with reloads are almost always due to buying them from people who take short cuts or do not stay on top of the process and materials. Gun show reload ammo is the common cause of issues.

Also, every gun is different in what it can tolerate and what it cannot. As previously posted, the Glock is a bit of a special case due to it's construction and materials. You will need to allow for that in the inspection of your materials and the number of times you reload spent casings.

Gun makers will always have a reload ammo caveat in the warranty. This is because they cannot assume a set standard in the product. You are not a ammunition supplier who is required to conform to exact standards and specifications, hence they cannot warranty the use of your "product" in theirs. Should the gun fail using factory ammo they can assume it was most likely correctly made and the failure is in the weapon. If a reload causes the failure they have no way of knowing if the problem was too much powder, worn casing, poor QC in the powder makers factory, etc, etc.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
333 Posts
Yes, all gunmakers have that caveat. Most will simply ignore it. GLOCK won't. If your gun blows up and you were using reloads, you'll have to pay for it to be fixed...
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
11,374 Posts
Shooting lead bullets through a glock barrel is like running 87 octane through an engine that calls for 92 octane. Can you get away with it? Maybe. But if you have a problem, it will be expensive to fix.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
35 Posts
No opinions here---If you have to reload for a Glock,of any caliber,
take the prudent safety precaution of using an aftermarket barrel
that can handle not only lead but SAMI pressures........................
GLOCK BARRELS CAN NOT
:cool:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
333 Posts
No opinions here---If you have to reload for a Glock,of any caliber,
take the prudent safety precaution of using an aftermarket barrel
that can handle not only lead but SAMI pressures........................
GLOCK BARRELS CAN NOT
:cool:
What? Can you cite anything that says otherwise?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
333 Posts
Sure-----can you be a little more specific as to what you would like me to
cite ? What do you refer to as "otherwise" ?

Browse info:

http://www.thegunzone.com/glock/kb-notes.html
(Golck has weak,unsupported barrels)
Much more info available if you care to see.
Check out "Glock ka-booms "on the web !
Citing the Gun Zone on GLOCKs being unsafe is like citing Moveon.org as to how good of a President Bill Clinton was. Dean Spier has a hard on against GLOCK, and manipulates or ignores facts on his "ka-boom" reports to better fit his agenda...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,861 Posts
So one side of the argument says don't do it unless you buy an aftermarket barrel with traditional lans/grooves. The other side of the argument says shoot what you want. Glock itself doesn't weigh in except with the standard legalize, "The use of reloaded ammunition will void the Glock warranty, due to the unpredictability of the standards (SAMI/NATO) adhered to, since reloads of poor quality ammunition may not meet (SAMI/NATO) specifications, may exceed limits, and therefore may be unsafe."
That's odd. IIRC, NATO spec'ed 9x19mm is over pressured when compared to a CIP or SAAMI spec'ed 9mm Parabellum.

Comparing 9mmx19 NATO and 9mm Parabellum is similar to comparing .223 Rem to 5.56x45 NATO.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
35 Posts
Hey ranger sxt---YOU asked for me to cite my references ! If you don't like them ,please refer to the remainder of my post and......look around the web.
The reference that I quoted is only a fraction of the info available....need
I quote more ? Please note that I use a KKM aftermarket
,fully supported,barrel and comp. in my gun and have had nothing but trouble free shooting !

Sounds like we may need to agree to disagree ?
( no opinions here !)
BTW----do you have any references to cite that may be pertinent ?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
35 Posts
For the safety of any Glock...the barrel should be replaced.

Long Wolf are good barrels and affordable.

Glock barrels are not heat treated and thus will fail. It is not a matter of IF but when. The net is full of Glock KB stories..Glock denies a problem but settles with injurred LEO's and tells civilian claims to go bump.

Replace the barrel and avoid the issue.
Hope this reference application works----------------------
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
35 Posts
#1 voids warranty

IF you want to safely shoot reloads, lead or jacketed, for your own protection and SAFETY....change the barrel to an after-market barrel that has been heat treated !

Far too many GLOCKS have been blown up with Factory loads...even more with reloads !

Glocks barrels DO NOT support the rear of the case like SAAMI spec replacement barrels.

PLEASE heed this warning and be safe !:)
One more for the masses(or ranger xst)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
35 Posts
My Glock 31 kabooomed , shooting PMC ammo. I got rid of the G31, but still have a 17 and a 37. Glock chambered for 40 S&W have a bad record. The Glock 40 S&W chamber is not only fully supported , but is 5/1000 OVER sammi specs. However, stick with Fed, Win or Rem factory ammo, and the 40 S&W will likely serve you well.
another for rangerxst...................................................
(no opionions here)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
333 Posts
Right. None of those are referencing the GLOCK barrels not handling SAAMI pressures. Since that's what factory ammo is loaded to, I would find it very suspect if GLOCK did not make their barrel be able to stand up to it. You have posted one person who had his gun blow-up on him, someone who claims to be a gunsmith, but makes even more ludicrous claims than you do and a review of a book. None of those can be considered an actual source saying that GLOCK barrels are not up to SAAMI pressures...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
35 Posts
Sorry that you fail to see any value,at all, in my offerings----
Perhaps some other thread would be to both our benefit.

Thanks for sharing the links to sights that you reference as being
your pods of wisdom.
I always try to learn from senior members with their infinite knowledge and learned postings.
 
1 - 20 of 32 Posts
Top