Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'General Handgun Discussion' started by Sunseeker, Oct 30, 2009.
What will be the best .45 for home defense. Consider a standard grip. Thanks
The one you shoot the best. Your question is like asking what kind of car is the best or what kind of food is the best.
Drop by the introductions area and tell us a bit about yourself and then maybe we can provide some good advice...
I agree 100% with NGIB. Outside of a glock, the gun you shoot best and best fits your hand.
Thompson machine gun.
If you have one I'm driving to your house tonight with 1,000 rds!
Michael Golden recommends his 460 XVR Magnum.
Thank you for your help. I have not been active for almost a decade. It was an honest question of what is going on the market nowdays. I guess I´ll buy a couple of magazines and find out.
Decades didn't change the 1911 Colt .45, still the gun others wish they were!!
"Being of the old school - the very old school - I wish to warn youthful readers against putting their faith in 'gun writers.' These people have a right to their opinions, but these opinions should not be taken as incontro-vertible. As a youth I was led astray on a number of subjects and had to learn of my errors by personal field experience. The fact that a man "has been there and done that" does not necessarily mean that he knows what he is talking about. Read as much as you wish, but read critically, and then submit your conclusions to the test. This is not always possible, so read carefully, read critically, and then reserve judgment. " Col. Jeff Cooper
If you'd at least provided a price range, we could actually provide some suggestions - but you offered us nothing to work with. Sorry if you're offended but none of us are mystics and we can't read your mind...
the 1911 is still pretty much the industry standard. however, the last time i shot .45s i was more accurate with the springfield xd.
but thats just me personally. you might like something else better.
you could always go to a range that rents guns and check a few different ones before you pick one to buy.
for the most part, i think any modern .45 will hit a person that's close enough to attack you so really any one would "work".
like the guy above said, it's really all about what you like personally.
Thanks NGIB, maybe my question was a little vague. I´ll start again. If I wanted to compete with the .45 I´ll probably buy an Infinity or a Sig. I just want something for close defense, then reliability will be the most important factor. I don´t want to waist my money but I don´t want to be cheap in this matter. I have never used Glock, I have to recognize that I have a little byass against guns that explodes in your hands, although this probably has been solved by now. I think that Walther is a better gun than HK, and Sig even better. I don´t now about M&P, although looks pretty good, and I have no idea about the rest. Can you help?
Go with a known brand name and spend no less than $500 and you'll be fine. If you want particulars then we need particulars.
What price range?
What will it be used for?
Polymer or steel?
We could give you many many suggestions, but you'll have to see which one fits you best and which you think is the prettiest.
p.s. Glocks won't blow up in your face, they just give tango fits,lol.
Um. Actually... I am.
I promise not to tell everyone that you sing Kelly Clarkson at the top of your lungs while driving to and from the range.
I have seen good reviews on the Rock Island .45. It appears to be a well made gun at a reasonable price.
Sunseeker-you're wanting a compact subcompact or full size pistol? Is it going to be carried daily? Are you wanting polymer, lightweight, or all steel frame? The 1911 platform or other type of platform? I commend you for selecting the .45 as caliber-it's the same caliber as what I chose.
I'll go out on a limb and give 2 suggestions:
For a polymer .45, the XD Compact is a great gun. I own very, very few plastic guns - but I have one of these. Accurate, reliable, and it doesn't look like a Glock. It's compact (for a .45) and holds 10 rounds - and you can use the extended mags to increase capacity for a home defense gun. I'm not a real fan of the full-size XD .45 as the grip is just to long and unwieldly.
For a steel .45, a Rock Island Tactical (or Citadel, or Metro Arms). Basically one of the "upper" level 1911s made in the Philippines. These have dovetailed sights and enough of the bells & whistles to make it a decent package. I do not suggest a "GI" version as many folks buy one to cut costs and immediately throw money at them for better sights.
Either of these will be in the $500 range...
.....and I've never seen a negative review of a handgun in any magazine...just my experience.
EXACTLY!!! Or even a book for that matter. I like Patrick Sweeney and have read most of his books (some twice), but he never really tells you which guns that were tested really sucked.
It's also hard to say: "You get what you pay for", because I have $500 guns that have never had a failure in thousands of rounds and I've had to send a $1000 gun back for adjustments after a few hundred.