I've got one in 44-40. Shoots to POA except it's high at 25 yds. The front sights are left tall so you can file them down to fit your loads and I'm just to lazy to do it.
I bought a new Cattlemen a couple weeks ago and it also shoots left. About 4inches left at 20ft. Looks like the front sight is not lined up with the rear sight groove. I think the barrel needs to be screwed in a little to get it aligned. Got a warranty repair order from the Benelli repair facility in Maryland and sent it there last week. They said they would get it back to me in a week.Picked up a Uberti SAA in 45 Colt the other day. Shoots and looks great. Only complaint is it shoots about 4 inches left at 15=20 yards. Have read this is not uncommon. Anyone have one? What are your views and does yours shoot left?