9mm CCW S&W M&P compact or Beretta PX4 sub-compact

Discussion in 'Semi-Auto Handguns' started by UberMonkey, Jul 10, 2008.

  1. UberMonkey

    UberMonkey New Member

    I am looking to purchase a 9mm CCW compact semi-auto. For various reasons, I have narrowed my search to the Smith & Wesson M&P series compact or the Beretta PX4 Storm sub-compact. Does anyone here have any useful input for me? Please keep responses polite...

  2. Olympicarmsfan

    Olympicarmsfan New Member

    I like the Smith & Wesson M&P and really like the price on them. I saw them in the shops a little over a year ago I guess and they were right at 400 maybe a little over that. I thought it felt good in my hand and I liked that it was easy to break down and clean. The only thing I dont like the the part that you take out on the grip. Im not sure of how well over time it will hold up. I dont know anything about the PX4 Storm.

    I carry a G19 everyday for my CCW not sure if you dont like Glock or if its the price. I think if I was going to pick my next CCW gun I would go with the M&P as I really liked not only the price but like I said how easy it was to take down and it was almost like my Glock in that department. Keep us posted and range report.

  3. h8dirt

    h8dirt New Member

    I recently had service problems with a new Walther (now owned by S&W). It took over two weeks to talk to a person and once I got the gun in for repair and back in my hands it was several weeks later. At that, I thought they did a sloppy repair job on a brand new pistol -- dirty, covered in graphite -- just sloppy. Maybe it was just bad luck on my part, but I had to work REALLY, REALLY hard to get poor service. Wish you well, hope this helps.
  4. mossberg kid

    mossberg kid Guest

    i say go with the m&p. i have a full size 40 and its great. Plus the 45 won pistol of the year thats gotta count for something haha but then again i know nothing about beretta
  5. mudpuppy

    mudpuppy New Member

    I don't have experience with the M&P, but I do own a full size PX4 9mm. It shoots flawlessly and is more accurate than I am. The only thing I would say about the PX4SC is that Beretta delayed about 2 years from announcing it until they finally started delivering it this summer. They had several false start delivery dates along the way. The full size PX4 has a rotating barrel, the PX4SC has a tilt barrel - don't know how that will play out over time, but the mechanisms are different. Many other semi-autos use the tilt barrel, so that is not a new concept. You might want to see how the first deliveries perform to see if there are any bugs that appear. As you know there are often things that don't crop up until the public gets their hands on the new design. On the positive side of the PX4SC:
    1. It has a safety/decocker (which I recommend) - which I wanted.
    2. It has an exposed hammer - so you can fire SA/DA - which I wanted
    3. It has exchangeable grip inserts to suit your hand size - which I wanted
    4. It is quality built and easy to maintain - which I wanted

    Personally, I waited quite a while to buy a PX4SC and finally gave up and bought a H&K P2000SK 9mm. What a sweet gun!!! It is out of the price range of the M&P & PX4SC, but if you can find a used one I would highly recommend checking it out.
  6. dnthmn2004

    dnthmn2004 New Member

    I have a full sized M&P 40 and I love it. I carry it everywhere without much problem, but I'm probably going to get a M&P 40 compact. Ive only had experience with one berretta a friend of mine had and I hated it. My personal opinion is go with a M&P, but try them both.