Firearms Talk banner

22lr pistol

1130 Views 27 Replies 18 Participants Last post by  echo1
May be in the market for a 22 pistol soon. What are your suggestions? Currently considering Ruger Mark IV 22/45, S&W SW22 Victory and Browning Buckmark but open to suggestions.
1 - 20 of 28 Posts
Taurus TX-22 or Ruger MKIV would be my choices. The MKIV/45 is polymer with a grip angle of a 1911 from what I've read. I like the all metal MKIV better. The Taurus TX-22 is also polymer, but so far I have had zero failures with mine and it's 16+1 capacity in the free states. I wish I would have gotten 1 each of the Ruger MK series, but the only one I have is a 1976-ish Standard. I had one I bought back in the 60s but stupidly sold it to my neighbor because I needed some cash at the time. Once I realized the error of my ways I got the 1976-ish model.

I don't know if they still make them but I also have a GSG/ATI 1911/22 that has been a great firearm. Their Firefly has been finicky in the past but after 2000rnds or so is also shooting as it should, and after polishing the almost tar-like substance off the feed ramp.

I would try to handle as many as you can and get the one that feels good in your hand and looks good to your eyes. If you can shoot them before buying is even better but guns that don't shoot well don't stay on the market very long. What I'm saying is most guns you see for sale have decent track records.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Oh...this needs to be moved to the PISTOL section!
Wife had an older Ruger 22/45 (Mk II or III) which I hated because of having to wrestle with it to clean - traded it in on a new Mk IV Hunter - haven't shot it yet but Hickok45 seems to like 'em :
My Standard can be a PITA to put back together, I did buy the insert to make it easier but I still have to hold it a weird way to make it work:

Ruger MK Reassembly |the One-Time Fix |Hammer Strut Support

I think the problem is I don't shoot it enough anymore too remember how to do it flawlessly!!! :rolleyes:

I recently bought a Ruger Security 380, easiest pistol I have to disassemble/assemble. The Colt Woodsman I have is just as finicky as the Ruger Standard/Mk series, maybe more so.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
May be in the market for a 22 pistol soon. What are your suggestions? Currently considering Ruger Mark IV 22/45, S&W SW22 Victory and Browning Buckmark but open to suggestions.
What do you plan to use the gun for?
Oh...this needs to be moved to the PISTOL section!
Moved.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
I say take the guess work out and buy one of each.
  • Like
Reactions: 4
All your choices are pretty good pistols. Personally, I own three Ruger Mark series pistols and I like them all. The early Standard model is the most accurate, even better than my Mark IV Target. Also have a Mark IV 22/45 Lite. Also have a S&W M&P Compact .22. It is a good little pistol too, but not as accurate as the Rugers. Another good option from Ruger is their Single Six revolvers (which may come with a .22 mag cylinder too). They are a fine SA revolver…very accurate. Of your choices I would go with the Ruger Mark IV.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
It depends on what you will be using it for.
Walther P22 - double action semi-auto. Lightweight. Fairly foolproof and less costly than some. Mine's the knock-around, toss-around farm pistol that uses the same rail-mounted flashlight as my Glock 22. Double action lets me "double tap" old, grungy cartridges I find laying around. It is NOT a target pistol, but it is a Walther - good customer service.

I have better pistols for target & handgun hunting, but it's dispatched many trapped raccoons near my chicken house.
Walther P22
I own a Walther P22. The one caveat I would add is that it can be difficult to reassemble after cleaning. I lost track of the number of times I had to chase the recoil spring around the room...
  • Like
Reactions: 4
I own a Walther P22. The one caveat I would add is that it can be difficult to reassemble after cleaning. I lost track of the number of times I had to chase the recoil spring around the room...
I found a captive recoil spring gizmo for maybe $15-$20 that absolutely solved that problem. Midway or Brownell's (don't remember). Yup, without it you might put your eye out. It's specifically for the P22 (I think). Some ol' boy was apparently having the same problem. Really makes cleaning a snap. Cheers.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
First you need to decide which type of .22 pistol do you want.

Do you want a target style such as the ones you mentioned,,,
Or do you want a duty style pistol like that Taurus or a Ruger SR-22.

Also, don't buy any pistol sight unseen,,,
You can select all the pertinent features you desire,,,
But if the pistol doesn't fit your hand you've wasted a lot of money.

I've seen this so often over the years,,,
A person chooses a gun because of the specs,,,
Then when they order it from Buds or any other place,,,
They find that it doesn't fit their hand and they are unhappy with it.

Go to as many major gun shops as you can,,,
Handle the pistols and see which of them make you smile.

Honestly, just about any modern pistol will probably suit the purpose,,,
Why not find the one that pleases you when you pick it up.

Aarond

.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
I have all 3 mentioned in the OP. And i like them all. I know not much help. Other than you can't go wrong with any of them.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Since we are discussing gun purchase in the USA, where many gun stores have their own ranges right there, why not either go to a range where you can rent a selection of possibles, or go to a gun store that can let you try a range of guns from their familiarisation stock?
  • Like
Reactions: 4
After doing a lot of research I bought a Browning Buckmark about 10 years ago. It's accurate and has never jammed or misfired. Easy to clean also.
Good luck
The Victory or even the Buckmark will give you a better trigger OOB. For an additional $200, the MKIV can be upgraded to a trigger that is outstanding. You will do well with any of these three, Kaymax934.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
The S&W Victory is so good that I bought a second one.
I have been the Ruger Mark route over the decades and now use only the Victory.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
I too, shoot my Victory more often than I shoot my MKIV.
The S&W Victory is so good that I bought a second one.
I have been the Ruger Mark route over the decades and now use only the Victory.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
1 - 20 of 28 Posts
Top