Firearms Talk banner
1 - 20 of 23 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
4 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Ok I'm new to this post but I really wanna get a 1911. I was thinking of either a Springfield or a Remington. What do you guys think?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
675 Posts
Either way, you are good to go. I'd take the springer as they have a great CS reputation. Get the mil-spec if you go springer. I really like the finish on the r1 though.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
664 Posts
Both are good choices however I would lean towards the Springfield
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
675 Posts
Not to sound silly but is there a difference in parkerized or stainless.
Yes. Stainless does not require a rust preventative as it will not rust easily. The 4100 steel (not stainless) needs to be parkerized, blued or coated to prevent rust. BTW, welcome to the forum!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,511 Posts
Yes there is a major difference. A parked finish is an applied finish like painting. SS is SS steel polished to a high gloss.

Parked.


SS
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,905 Posts
Parkerizing is a method of building up a crystaline structure on the surface of the metal through using a phosphoric acid bath. It is kind of a controlled rusting / chemical reaction. The crystaline structure then works to trap oil and hold it on the metal to protect it.

Stainless steel is a different alloy than carbon steel.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
21,822 Posts
Get the Springer. (Or a Colt)
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
0 Posts
i have owned several Springfield 1911's over the years and have not had any complaints with their function, quality or durability. they are top notch 1911's IMO. i currently have a SA Micro Compact 45 that is my most expensive 1911 to date and can say honestly, it is worth every dollar spent in buying it! pure pleasure to shoot, has functioned beautifullly with all ammo put through it, and pretty dang accurate for a short 3" barreled pistol. i highly recommend the Springfield 1911's.

i bought a Remington R1 Enhanced earlier this year. very pleased with it so far. excellent fit an finish, very accurate, handles all ammo i have put through it and shoots great. i have owned many Remington firearms over the years, but it's the first Remington pistol i have ever owned. i am very pleased with it and have no regrets in buying it. as said an excellent pistol. the only downside i see with the R1 is they use the Colt Series 80 type system. so any mods would require the Series 80 parts to make changes to the firing system. now mine shoots great as is, so it is quite possible that i will probably never make any changes to the firing system, unless it develops a problem. currently the only changes i have made are more personal and cosmetic. grips, grip screws, mag release, and better quality magazines.

these are my personal opinions on both of these 1911's and hope they help you make a decision in your choice. IMO, i don't think you will go wrong with whichever one you decide upon. and in Cane's opinion, i would also suggesst checking out Colt as well. there are a few of the Colt 1911's in the same price range as the Remington R1 Enhanced and a few of the SA 1911's that should be considered as well. i will say this, you can never go wrong with the Colt 1911.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,928 Posts
i have owned several Springfield 1911's over the years and have not had any complaints with their function, quality or durability. they are top notch 1911's IMO. i currently have a SA Micro Compact 45 that is my most expensive 1911 to date and can say honestly, it is worth every dollar spent in buying it! pure pleasure to shoot, has functioned beautifullly with all ammo put through it, and pretty dang accurate for a short 3" barreled pistol. i highly recommend the Springfield 1911's.

i bought a Remington R1 Enhanced earlier this year. very pleased with it so far. excellent fit an finish, very accurate, handles all ammo i have put through it and shoots great. i have owned many Remington firearms over the years, but it's the first Remington pistol i have ever owned. i am very pleased with it and have no regrets in buying it. as said an excellent pistol. the only downside i see with the R1 is they use the Colt Series 80 type system. so any mods would require the Series 80 parts to make changes to the firing system. now mine shoots great as is, so it is quite possible that i will probably never make any changes to the firing system, unless it develops a problem. currently the only changes i have made are more personal and cosmetic. grips, grip screws, mag release, and better quality magazines.

these are my personal opinions on both of these 1911's and hope they help you make a decision in your choice. IMO, i don't think you will go wrong with whichever one you decide upon. and in Cane's opinion,
i would also suggesst checking out Colt as well. there are a few of the Colt 1911's in the same price range as the Remington R1 Enhanced and a few of the SA 1911's that should be considered as well. i will say this, you can never go wrong with the Colt 1911.
I think many don't concider Colt because most assume the Colt just cost more-Thanks for pointing that out :cool:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
21,822 Posts
I think many don't concider Colt because most assume the Colt just cost more-Thanks for pointing that out :cool:
Colt's are bargain basement compared to Kimber. (In price ONLY)
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
0 Posts
Colt's are bargain basement compared to Kimber. (In price ONLY)
Kimber makes some really nice looking 1911's. a few i would not mine having, but until their prices come down, warranty period goes up and better CS, i highly doubt i will buy one. there are just too many others with a better price, longer warranty and better CS that will get my business instead.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
1,464 Posts
COLT!

Why buy anything else as your first.
??
 

·
Retired
Joined
·
13,651 Posts
Let's just say the there is not a Kimber in my safe.
 
1 - 20 of 23 Posts
Top