.17 HMR revolver

Discussion in 'Concealed Carrying & Personal Protection' started by IDVague, Feb 19, 2011.

  1. IDVague

    IDVague New Member

    202
    0
    0
    Give me some thoughts on the .17 HMR revolver as a personal defense option for a female with recoil issues. Would a .22 be just as good for this application?
     
  2. Neophyte1

    Neophyte1 New Member

    407
    0
    0
    .22 Better Choice

    IDVague: Sir, .17 is an outstanding round; when applied to a more proper application.
    .22, for practice, and all around, ''based'' against the .17; is the better choice.

    ask her to practice, take her to practice; and teach her the routine in basic's. :) then:) you have a built in shooting partner:)
     

  3. kilogulf59

    kilogulf59 New Member

    106
    0
    0
    Has she tried at least .380 in a larger pistol such as a Beretta Cheetah?

    .17's lose a lot in a handgun length barrel and, like a .22, they're small and light. I refer you to this article The Mouse That Roared.

    IMO if she simple can't or wont go any bigger than a .22, get a good .22 revolver or automatic, use Aguila Interceptor 40 grn LRN for carry and any good .22 for practice.

    I doubt the terminal effects of the .17 vs the .22 will mean much in actual application.

    Do your best to get her the largest caliber she can handle...
     
  4. IDVague

    IDVague New Member

    202
    0
    0
    Thanks for the help, everyone. The lady in question is the wife of a friend, so I'm going on his reports, but the word is that both his .380 and .22 Magnum are more that she can or will get used to shooting without flinching terribly. Neither he nor I have any experience with the .17, so we don't know if the recoil would be significantly different from the .22 or not. She can shoot a small frame .22 fairly well, so that might be the best that he can do for her. I know I would rather have a .22 than nothing, and in some cases I might prefer it over something larger.
     
  5. Sniper03

    Sniper03 Supporting Member Supporter

    7,665
    61
    48
    ID,

    Sounds like she needs some professional training from an instructor. And there are other issues like noise and proper ear protection that pays a very important role in developing bad habits like flinching. I only know of one individual in all the years that we could not teach to shoot when properly instructed and worked with. Not being able to handle a 22 Mag or 380 is an issue. I think this situation you are referring to just goes down to a plain training issue. And exposing here to techniques that can eliminate the flinching. Then there is the issue that if you are going to have a pistol that will stop an assailant especially one on drugs or nuts. It will take a caliber of around 380 at least to be consistent. I know there will be some that stand up against what I just stated. But the 380 is marginal when we talk about constantly being able to accomplish the task. It was the minimum that was allowed on the Metro PD for that reason. They also have some very good rounds for the 380 now which they did not have in the past.


    03
     
  6. 7point62

    7point62 Lifetime Supporting Member Lifetime Supporter

    2,188
    0
    0
    Unless you hit the vitals--and that's not likely from a newbie shooter in an adrenal rush--those tiny calibers are liable to just p*ss the attacker off.

    Qualified instruction with a small frame .38 would be my advice.
     
  7. JTJ

    JTJ Well-Known Member Supporter

    9,535
    129
    63
    Use 40 gr solids. You will need all the penetration you can get.
     
  8. sweeper22

    sweeper22 New Member

    2,706
    0
    0
    My only suggestion would be a 327 Federal Mag. It is a bigger round than what you're talking about here, but it can fire 4 calibers I believe (327mag, 32H&R mag, 32S&W long, and 32S&W)...the latter two being pretty tame.

    The only problem is that they're not terribly common, so it won't be the easiest gun to track down for a test run. I know Ruger offers both the SP101 and GP100 models in 327mag.
     
  9. WDB

    WDB New Member

    3,977
    2
    0
    3rd party training is in order IMHO. If she shys at a .22 there isn't a lot left. With some objective trigger time with a .22 she will either learn or be one of those that simply are not firearm friendly. I heard there are those that don't want to have anything to do with firearms but don't have any first hand expereince.
     
  10. kilogulf59

    kilogulf59 New Member

    106
    0
    0
    If she's that bad I have to question her willingness to use any firearm...
     
  11. Mark F

    Mark F New Member Supporter

    2,918
    0
    0
    Not everyone is cut-out for gun carrying/shooting. She just may be one of those people. She mat be better off with pepper spray or something similar.