XD's on top of my Short List!

Discussion in 'XD Forum' started by Blackbeard1718, Oct 26, 2010.

  1. Blackbeard1718

    Blackbeard1718 New Member

    189
    0
    0
    Ahoy!

    I've been researching a variety of Handgun Brands, for the past couple of weeks. I'm looking for Reliability, Accuracy, Minimal Recoil, CCW Capable, Large Magazine Capacity, and FUN to shoot at the Range.

    I've looked at Ruger, Glock, Bersa, Taurus, S&W, and Springfield Armory. I keep coming back to Springfield Armory, specifically their XD Models. I like what I've read, and also the many videos out there on the web.

    As I mentioned above, I want CCW Capability, but then again, I want something I can have FUN with at the Range.

    Having narrowed it down to two, I was considering the Sub-Compact XD9 with 3" Barrel and 13+1/16+1 Mags, and the XD9 with the 4" Barrel and 16+1 Mags. I REALLY like the Case and Bonus Items that SA includes in their kits. Not to mention, their current promotion with the 3 Extra Mags and Mag Holder Give-Away.

    Having read a lot of posts on this Forum, I've learned that I may not be happy with the 3" Barrel as a Range Pistol. Also mentioned, a 4” Barrel with Standard Grip may be too bulky for a CCW weapon. So, I thought… why not get both? I could use the Sub-Compact XD9 with 3” Barrel and Short Grip as my CCW, and the XD9 with the 4” Barrel and Standard Grip as my Range Pistol.

    Thennnnn ….. I went to Academy Sports today! They had a XDM9 with a 4.5” Barrel and 19+1 Mags. I liked the extra Backstraps that are included in the kit too. I tried a hand fit of a XD9 with 4” Barrel with Standard Grip, and also got a handful of the XDM9 as well. Oddly, the XDM felt lighter in the grip, than the XD did, even though the XDM is considered heavier, according to the Specs.

    There aren’t any places locally to rent any XD’s, to allow me to get a feel for them at the Range. So, I’m going to have to make the right selection when I purchase, the first time.

    FYI, I’m a 54 yo, that had By-Pass Heart Surgery nine years ago. My ribcage has been sliced-n-diced, and re-wired back together. Obviously, I’m trying to find something that has as little recoil as possible. Hopefully, one of these XD’s/XDM’s will fit the bill.

    Any inputs from you Handgun Vets out there, would be most appreciated!

    This is my First Post, and I plan on doing an Intro in the proper Thread tomorrow! I wanted to put this out there tonight, since I’m planning on buying within the next week or two, and I wanted to get your insight on which XD Model would/wouldn’t be the right choice for me.

    Thanks!

    Cheers!

    BB
     
  2. fixxer

    fixxer New Member

    188
    0
    0
    Hey Blackbeard,
    I've had the original XD the first year it came out under the Sprinfield name. As I recall, (and I might be wrong), it took the award for firearm of the year when it came out and then subsequently for a few years after. I had to part with mine several years ago after a bad chain of events (it was almost brand new too) and I can say that it was the only pistol I have parted with that I wish I had back (including the venerable small framed Kimber UCPII, which I hated). I was looking to buy a copy of my XD and then I got to handle my brother in law's XDM. The XDM is a very well handling pistol. It feels better in the hand than my new Glock 19RTF2. The trigger feels great too. I read a lot of articles where people will tell you to buy what you will carry but I feel like it is better for me to carry what I shoot at the range. Just a little extra weight and larger frame will make a drastic difference in the way it handles, how much it will beat you up; in turn, making it more fun to shoot. I personally am between carry pistols right now because I just moved states and I need to get my CCW straight (so I carry a Taser IWB for the time being). When I get my CCW back from Kansas, I will probably carry my G19 until my Springfield 1911 is fully broken in and proven. I have no qualms with carrying a full size pistol (40oz empty!) but I haven't tried since I had my Beretta. I have not shot the 3.5" barrel version but have been told it is surprisingly accurate. Of course "surprisingly accurate" for a 3.5" barrel isn't saying too terribly much at the range since its intended to hit center mass within the personal average defense area. LOL I'm sure the XDM 3.5" will do much better than that. For a combined CCW/range gun, I would prefer the 4.5" barrel that you are referring to. The difference in it's carry size would be noticible but not enough to keep someone from carrying it. The trend I've noticed is that people tend to start leaning towards full frame pistols as the become more confident in carrying. If you read a couple of Masaab Ayoob's articles about what he's carrying (and the commander sized Les Baer 1911 they made to his specs) and you'll start to get warm-fuzzies about that 4.5" barrel length! I still feel like someone's going to spot my printing even though most "good" guys are normally not looking for it. I have seen 1 person do a double take at me when I hurriedly/stupidly bent over to pick up the wallet I dropped as I came untucked accidently. That was with a full frame Beretta 92 (Hey, it's what us squids were tought with back then!). In retrospect, he would have spotted a little PPK under those conditions. I've never bought a pistol from Sportsman's Academy but I would if I could. I live out of state from the Academy so I cannot buy a pistol there. I bought tons of ammo from the one in Amarillo, TX before I moved though. I don't see how you could go wrong with that pistol and thier firearms prices seem to be very fair. Just my $.02.
     

  3. Jpyle

    Jpyle New Member

    4,844
    0
    0
  4. Jpyle

    Jpyle New Member

    4,844
    0
    0
    LOL...Dude you could have been wearing a bear skin and not have concealed that Beretta 92...:D
     
  5. sweeper22

    sweeper22 New Member

    2,706
    0
    0
    I'd recommend the XD9 or XD45 in the 4" Compact frame. They're similar in size to a Glock 19/23.

    They're small enough to conceal, big enough to work as range/service sidearm, and have very good capacity. I have an XD45 compact and really like it with the standard 10rd mags, but 12rd entended grip mags are available. I believe the 9mm version houses 16rds. The recoil of the 45acp is only moderately stronger than a 9mm IMO, though you may find different.

    XDms are fine guns, but they're big. I have the XDm45. It'd only be a practical carry option in colder weather, though I can't imagine a senario where I'd carry it over the compact. My $700 XDm is really cool, but I have to say my $450 XD compact is more useful...and the two shoot equally well.
     
  6. Gojubrian

    Gojubrian New Member

    6,262
    0
    0
  7. fixxer

    fixxer New Member

    188
    0
    0
    Nice setup. Is that a Cross Breed holster? It looks kinda like one but it is more squared off than I seen on their website... I'd like to have one while I wait for my Milt Sparks to get made.
     
  8. Gojubrian

    Gojubrian New Member

    6,262
    0
    0
    A guy here in Arkansas makes these. It's a Theis holster, every bit as good as a supertuck, but a lot less expensive.
     
  9. mcramer

    mcramer New Member

    161
    0
    0
    A buddy of mine carries a XD .45 compact as his backup weapon when he's working. The standard magazines for that are 10rnd, but also have the 13rnd magazines with the grip extension. the 10rnd mags are small enough that it is concealed. He used to carry his on his ankle, and unless you knew it was there, you couldn't see any bulge or bulky-ness around the ankle area. the small magazines are also comfortable enough for someone with big hands like myself.
     
  10. DragonLW

    DragonLW New Member

    26
    0
    0
    Blackbeard....

    PM Sent. :)
     
  11. fixxer

    fixxer New Member

    188
    0
    0
    In retrospect, I could see where the XDM is a larger pistol for CCW. I chaulked it up to that fact that it was a larger caliber than my XD was but XDM slides are all probably the same size. The XD is probably a good choice, especially in 9mm. I would guess that the slides would be a little narrower. Since the XD and XDM shoot equally well, then I think you're right on target choosing the XD. I liked mine alot.
    Blackbeard, I think you should definitely stick to the 9mm since that is what you feel comfortable with. I seen muzzle control concerns were what you emphasized when you stated that you had been sliced and diced and stitched back together. I see people have already started recommending that you step up to the .45acp platform. This happens on every forum that I've read where people mention that they're looking for 9mm recommendations. I suspect you have taken many things into consideration to determine that the 9mm platform is right for you. I also think that there isn't much to be gained in the area of "stopping power" when your 9mm is firing Lawman, SXT or the likes.
     
    Last edited: Oct 29, 2010
  12. Blackbeard1718

    Blackbeard1718 New Member

    189
    0
    0
    FOUND IT! The perfect gun, that is! I stopped by my local gun shop on Wednesday afternoon, and he had just received an XDM-9 with a 3.8" Barrel. I tried it for fit and weight, and it was right where I needed it to be!

    It's not long like the XDM9 4.5" Barrel, and just a bit shorter than the XD9 4" Barrel. Too boot, it's a 19+1 Mag, as opposed to the XD9's 16+1 Mag. Hey! Those extra three rounds could certainly make a difference some day!

    I've been thinking about it the past few days, and did a bit more research on the 3.8. The one I looked at had the Stock 3-Dot Sights. I think I'm going to splurge a little, and order the one that has the Night Sights. Since it's going to be my CCW and my Range Pistol, I may as well do it right the first time out.

    I'm heading back over to the gun shop on Monday, to make the purchase. Once I've got it in-hand, I'll take a few pics. I feel like a kid at Christmas! Looks like it's coming early this year.

    Some of you may think the 3.8 may be a bit big for a CCW Pistol, but..... consider this..... I'm 6'1" and 250+, wear baggy Cargo Shorts, and Pocket T-'s that go over my waist, all year round. So, I shouldn't have a problem with concealing it. I found an, In-The-Pants Holster, made by "Uncle Mike's", that seems like it'll do the trick for me. I'll wait until I actually buy the gun Monday, before I buy any accessories just yet. Just looking right now.

    Thanks to ALL OF YOU, for your feedback and suggestions! They were certainly extremely helpful in making my decision.

    Cheers!

    BB
     
  13. Jpyle

    Jpyle New Member

    4,844
    0
    0
    Congrats and best of luck with the new XDm. Now just be sure to post some pics and a range report...:p Have fun, that's a nice shooter...
     
  14. SGT_Calle

    SGT_Calle New Member

    130
    0
    0
    Glad you found something you like! I still had to chime in and second the XD45c. I had a XD40 4" that I liked a lot then traded it for the 45 (which seems to be a little more gentle shooter). Being tall and very thin, I've found that the compact grip does conceal a little better. A good holster, like a crossbreed supertuck, will help as well.
     
  15. fixxer

    fixxer New Member

    188
    0
    0
    Congratulations

    Naw, I'm with you. I don't think that XDM will be too large. Especially the short barrel version. Congrats. I'm sure you'll get a lot of enjoyment out of it.
     
  16. Blackbeard1718

    Blackbeard1718 New Member

    189
    0
    0
    I ordered it today, and it'll be here next week. Can't wait! I'll get some pics and do a Review as well, when I have it in hand.

    Cheers!

    BB
     
  17. gorknoids

    gorknoids New Member

    2,431
    0
    0
    Congrats on your choice, BB! I'm a big fan of the XD 9, because there's nothing spectacular about it. It simply suits my needs, my hands, and my idea of what maintainability is all about. Remember that XD stands for "extreme duty", and they did not over-reach with that moniker. 19 rounds means you can load her in January and shoot it through September! I can only shoot until August 26th....:D
     
  18. pistolero_loco

    pistolero_loco New Member

    20
    0
    0
    XD

    As many will tell you, the most important aspect of owning any CCW is practice. So it makes sense to me to buy the same gun in a carry version and a range gun. The XD's are inexpensive and excellent pistols. Why not buy a 3" barrel XD, and then get another a size or two bigger? The guns will operate almost identically. I have a Glock 26 and a Glock 17 for this reason. I am considering adding a Springfield 3" XD. I believe the "compact" XDM is just too big and heavy to carry. If you consider that you would pay around $1000 for a Kimber or $900 for an HK, I'd go with two XD's and you're not spending much more.
     
  19. chevelle427

    chevelle427 New Member

    45
    0
    0
    been carrying a xdsc40 for 2 years now and have picked up a few more now i think im hooked