Originally Posted by JonM
do you think it is a good idea to crank off rounds into the ground or the sky or whatever as a method of self defense??
there was a good outcome but consider if that round had of hit a rock under the dirt and plunked into the skull of one of his 14 grandkids...
my point is that it is not beyound justice to fine him for reckless discharge when he was likely in no danger. since he did not see sufficient threat to shoot the guy he should not have shot his gun off.
no use of force class or ccw training i have ever taken or even heard off directs a citizen to crank off rounds in a random direction to "scare" people.
Firing rounds into the air is NEVER
a good idea, but doing what he did worked.
You can "suppose" till the cows come home but it doesn't mean it happened. Fact is he didn't fire into the sky, hit a rock and ricochet into one of his grandkids or have black gold come bubblin' out of the ground. Fact is none of that happened.
It is also a fact that the best training classes on the planet do not and cannot prepare for every isolated circumstance, and Grandpa may not have had any training at all. He did not "crank off rounds in a random direction to "scare" people", he fired one single round into the ground in front of himself (presumably) as a warning that he was armed with a gun and was willing to use it in order to get the bad guy to stop and comply with his orders.
JonM, what would you do if you were faced with a situation that was not covered in your extensive training (or perhaps a perp who has not been through the same training)? Call your instructor
? Wet your pants
? Or improvise, adapt and overcome
? Personally I would hope that I would do the latter.
Again, Grandpa apprehended the bad guy and held him without injury until the police arrived. I see nothing wrong with that. The only
thing that went wrong in my opinion was Grandpa's arrest.