Firearm & Gun Forum - FireArmsTalk.com

Firearm & Gun Forum - FireArmsTalk.com (http://www.firearmstalk.com/forums/)
-   XD Forum (http://www.firearmstalk.com/forums/f59/)
-   -   Springfield XD Tactical in 357 Sig. (http://www.firearmstalk.com/forums/f59/springfield-xd-tactical-357-sig-61670/)

morayman 04-02-2012 05:47 PM

Springfield XD Tactical in 357 Sig.
 
We just ordered a XD in 357 Sig.I haven't been able to find much about this cal. in XD's.Do any of you shoot The 357 Sig?, how do you like it if you do? Thanks morayman...........

Riverg420 04-02-2012 06:51 PM

I carry a 229 .357 sig and a 239 .357 sig . I personally find it more acurate than a .40 and more of a punch than a 9mm .Basically it's a 9mm on steriods

ZombieBrawler 04-02-2012 10:44 PM

Fimilliar with xd's but not that cal. Is that all just a beefy 9mm?

JonM 04-03-2012 01:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZombieBrawler (Post 759680)
Fimilliar with xd's but not that cal. Is that all just a beefy 9mm?

357sig is a lightweight short case length version of the 357mag. its on the same power level as lighter than 158grn 357mag loads. it was developed explicitly at the request of the texas highway patrol for a powerful auto loading cartridge with superb barrier and glass penetration qualities.

those requirments were needed because the thp often are having to shoot through car bodies and windshield glass. at this the round really excels. its an extreme over penetrator in some loadings.

loading for the 357 sig is not as easy as most pistol cartridges.

it is a fun cartridge to shoot and congrats to the OP on picking an excellent round

my opinion: its an excellent self defense round if barrier penetration is a real concern. its also a very good alternative to the 10mm. ammo can be difficult to find as its primarily a LE round. my thinking is skip it for normal SD use.

ZombieBrawler 04-03-2012 05:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JonM

357sig is a lightweight short case length version of the 357mag. its on the same power level as lighter than 158grn 357mag loads. it was developed explicitly at the request of the texas highway patrol for a powerful auto loading cartridge with superb barrier and glass penetration qualities.

those requirments were needed because the thp often are having to shoot through car bodies and windshield glass. at this the round really excels. its an extreme over penetrator in some loadings.

loading for the 357 sig is not as easy as most pistol cartridges.

it is a fun cartridge to shoot and congrats to the OP on picking an excellent round

my opinion: its an excellent self defense round if barrier penetration is a real concern. its also a very good alternative to the 10mm. ammo can be difficult to find as its primarily a LE round. my thinking is skip it for normal SD use.

No kidding my curiosity was its relation to the .357 mag. But hey what ever floats your boat i just use .45's :)

morayman 04-03-2012 11:45 AM

I've shot the round and loved it,it's accurate and has all the power you'd need.It's a man stopper with over 90% one shot stops and yes it will penetrate with certain loads.I figured if it's good enough for the Secret Service it's probably good enough for me! I just don't hear much about it in the XD platform.morayman..........

JonM 04-03-2012 12:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by morayman (Post 760224)
I've shot the round and loved it,it's accurate and has all the power you'd need.It's a man stopper with over 90% one shot stops and yes it will penetrate with certain loads.I figured if it's good enough for the Secret Service it's probably good enough for me! I just don't hear much about it in the XD platform.morayman..........

I would be tempted to get one if it was on the xdm lineup. Its got a wide array of bullet choices for the reloader that can make it a very very potent choice

THEAKDUDE 05-03-2012 03:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JonM

357sig is a lightweight short case length version of the 357mag. its on the same power level as lighter than 158grn 357mag loads. it was developed explicitly at the request of the texas highway patrol for a powerful auto loading cartridge with superb barrier and glass penetration qualities.

those requirments were needed because the thp often are having to shoot through car bodies and windshield glass. at this the round really excels. its an extreme over penetrator in some loadings.

loading for the 357 sig is not as easy as most pistol cartridges.

it is a fun cartridge to shoot and congrats to the OP on picking an excellent round

my opinion: its an excellent self defense round if barrier penetration is a real concern. its also a very good alternative to the 10mm. ammo can be difficult to find as its primarily a LE round. my thinking is skip it for normal SD use.

jeez wikipedia

morayman 05-03-2012 05:49 PM

Thanks for your valuable input. morayman............

msup752 05-03-2012 08:23 PM

I carried a Sig 229 and a Glock 32 for years. .357 sig has outstanding penetration. It was also easy to reload but very expensive to buy factory ammo. I often used formed .40 brass that the State Police shot at my former employer's range.
I liked a lot more than 40 for both reliability, penetration, and cheaper to reload.
Eventually I sold them all off (I had an H&K in .357 sig as well) and went with 9mm for even more cost efficiency and caliber consolidation.
Speer Gold Dot HP's are as good as it gets in this caliber. They are designed specifically for the higher velocity while most others use 9mm design bullets.
The recoil is sharp, the report is loud, and the muzzle flash is significant. Reloads with Power Pistol creep up on 1400 FPS for 125 grain bullets.


All times are GMT. The time now is 07:21 AM.

Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.