Firearm & Gun Forum - FireArmsTalk.com

Firearm & Gun Forum - FireArmsTalk.com (http://www.firearmstalk.com/forums/)
-   XD Forum (http://www.firearmstalk.com/forums/f59/)
-   -   Conversion barrel .40 -> 9mm, gun noob (http://www.firearmstalk.com/forums/f59/conversion-barrel-40-9mm-gun-noob-32792/)

Stuflames 10-08-2010 08:54 AM

Conversion barrel .40 -> 9mm, gun noob
 
I've been researching pistols with the intention of buying my first, I'm almost positive that what I want is a XDm model in the .40.

However I primarily want to use and fire 9mm ammo. The .40 will be there mainly for:
- fun (mixing up the ammo types)
- so I can have a good pile of reasonably powerful ammunition without investing in large amounts of premium 9mm ammo
- in case my tastes change or I feel I need the extra weight and force of the .40
- so I can take advantage of sales or price drops due to some massive surplus for either type of ammo as they come about. I intend on keeping this gun for a long time and I'm a young man so I imagine over I'll make a good chunk of this investment back.

But, again, I do plan on making this a primarily 9mm handgun.

So as someone new to all this, I was wondering if I could have some feedback on:

1. Is it reasonable to buy a .40 with the intention of using a changed-out barrel for most of its life? Besides gun dimensions/weight and the extra cost of equipment is there any possible disadvantage in using the .40 frame to primarily shoot 9mm rounds over just getting the 9mm frame?

2. The barrels I'm looking at (from Storm Lake barrels) have some options:
-Extra length: does the stock holster accommodate the extra length of the barrel? Seems nice for a bit of extra power/accuracy. . .thoughts? Also this is a pre-requisite for:
-Ported barrels: Do they have a use beyond cosmetics? What are they all about?
-Threading. Silencers are illegal in my state, but in the event I moved or. . .something. . .as long as I'm getting an extra barrel this extra features seems like a "why not". . .sure straight up they're a little ugly but with the "thread protectors" available it seems they'd look pretty sharp. Anything further to note?

3. I've heard talk of setting the spring to 18. . .or something. I'm still not very gun-savvy what does this mean? Does it require another part, a separate spring component? If so is that easy to acquire/install?

4. Other thoughts?

Thanks for any help!

Stuflames 10-08-2010 09:41 AM

-Threading. Silencers are illegal in my state, but in the event I moved or. . .something. . .as long as I'm getting an extra barrel this extra features seems like a "why not". . .sure straight up they're a little ugly but with the "thread protectors" available it seems they'd look pretty sharp. Anything further to note?

I forgot to ask also: there's a number of different available threading types. Is there any middle standard that I should get? Any advice for how to decide which one to choose?

Stuflames 10-08-2010 06:01 PM

A 9mm is a lot easier to controle, it is plenty enough power to stop a person trying to harm you, the ammo is pretty cheap which will allow you to shoot more. More practice equals better shooting.

None of this precludes my reason for wanting the .40 version too, and all are the reasons why I would, for now, primarily be using the 9mm barrel if I went this route.

I'm starting to think that I will just get the 9mm, though, and at some later date when I have more money for, well, everything, I'll get something in 10mm and then get my .40 fix from that as well.

I really, really want that Kel-Tec PMR 30 when it becomes reasonably available and if I blow my money on the conversion kit and extra .40 ammo I might not be able to get that and be comfortable with the amount of money I've been spending.

Long story short, I will probably follow your advice and just get the 9mm, but not exactly for those reasons.;)

Stuflames 10-09-2010 03:37 AM

I'm still not buying until tomorrow, though, so if anyone has any information on the questions above that might make the .40 with a 9mm conversion appealing I'd listen. . .I'm still torn. . .

Stuflames 10-10-2010 06:13 AM

Bought the 9mm. . .has more kick than I expected just from internet research, I very much doubt I'll regret this.

The difficulty of releasing a full mag was not exaggerated in my case, though, I needed some outside leverage to do it, no way was I able to do it on my own strength. Also loading a mag to the full 19 would be extremely difficult for me without the reload assister.

Rick1967 10-10-2010 12:27 PM

I own many guns. From 22 lr to 44mag. But, I would never be afraid to defend myself with a 9mm. You made a good choice.

ElvisIsDead 10-10-2010 01:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rick1967 (Post 365984)
I own many guns. From 22 lr to 44mag. But, I would never be afraid to defend myself with a 9mm. You made a good choice.

Very good answer. I too own everything from 9mm to .44 Mag. My two favorite personal defense rounds are the .357 Mag or the .45 ACP but the 9mm, placed well, will get the job done every time.

willfully armed 10-11-2010 04:21 AM

98% of the year, I carry a 9mm. HK or Glock.

hunting season, you'll find me with a Glock 10mm.


All times are GMT. The time now is 07:13 PM.

Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.