Firearm & Gun Forum - FireArmsTalk.com

Firearm & Gun Forum - FireArmsTalk.com (http://www.firearmstalk.com/forums/)
-   Ammunition & Reloading (http://www.firearmstalk.com/forums/f30/)
-   -   Cartridge Of The Day. (http://www.firearmstalk.com/forums/f30/cartridge-day-101307/)

Axxe55 12-08-2013 04:37 AM

Cartridge Of The Day.
 
i like guns and shooting and like many people who shoot, i like to reload as well. i find it to be a useful, but rewarding addition to shooting, bringing almost as much enjoyment to me as shooting guns does.

but this thread will not be specifically about reloading, but about cartridges. their history. their ballistics and comparisons to other cartridges and our thoughts and opinions of them, and why we are partial to some over others.

the idea behind this thread is to have a discussion about a particular cartridge for about a day or so, then moving onto another. it can be a current cartridge or an older one, or an obsolete one or even a wildcat.

the floor is open to whomever wishes to start the discussion.........

JonM 12-08-2013 05:41 AM

how bout the 45-70?? one of my favorites. very versatile in a wide array of bullets from big 500grainers to 200 grain speed demons.

im loading up a favorite recipe tomorrow in 45-70 which is a 350grn hornady rn over 45 grains of reloader7 thats somewhere around 1700fps. plenty for whatever your doing.

if i need a flatter shooter i pull out my 458winmag using the same bullet and about 83grains of a2230 hums em out at 2500fps with about the same trajectory to 300yds as a 308

so down in texas most shots are 100 or much less and nothing really over 300 where i hunt yotes hogs and deer the 45-70 and 458winmag are perfect for the terrain

Axxe55 12-08-2013 05:52 AM

the 45-70 is a great cartridge with a lot of rich history behind it. very good one to start a discussion about.

i don't have a lot experiance with this one, but it is one that has help my interest for a great number of years. i have shot a few single shots in this cartrdge and very much enjoyed them and made me want one even more.

but this past summer, i got my first opportunity to shoot one in a Marlin lever action that Robo was kind enough to allow me try out. i was pleasantly suprised that the recoil wasn't as stiff as i expected in such a light rifle. vey nice shooting rifle. has made me rethink getting a lever action vs. the single shot i had thought about. my thanks to Robo for that opportunity.

a very large case that can shoot a large chunk of lead downrange!

JonM 12-08-2013 06:00 AM

with certain powders like rl7 which has a low pressure buildup and in the marlin action you can hit starting loads for the 458winmag with the 45-70...

it can get quite recoily when your doing that. i typically stick to about 1600-1700 fps with the 45-70 as ive got bigger guns for going faster if i want that power level. 1700 is right in the same identical loading as the 458 socom using 350 grainers. one of the reasons i like the socom. its asemi auto friendly 45-70

a lightweight short rifle like a 1895gbl pushing 2000 fps with 350grainers is very stout recoil put the same speed in a bigger longer barreled winchester mod 70 and it comes out more like a 12ga slug in felt recoil.

robocop10mm 12-08-2013 06:05 AM

My "standard" load for the Guide Gun is my HARD cast 340 gr FN @ 2100 fps. I have yet to find the utility pole or feral hog that can stop that bullet. I will not publish the load as it is quite warm

nitestalker 12-08-2013 06:13 AM

I like and own so many I will start with my favorite "Varmint" round. That is the old tried and true .220 Swift. The Swift is an off spring of the 1898 era Remington-Lee Straight pull Navy 6MM round. It has been around in one form or other for the past 80 plus years.
My uncles used them from the 1930s into the late 1950s. I grew up with Swifts. It is a hand-loaders cartridge and is great across the open spaces. The "Barrel" burn out yarns in modern properly cleaned barrels is a non-issue.
I own a number of Swifts. My favorite take along is an older Ruger Number One HB with a variable scope. It is great on Prairie Dogs, Jack Rabbits and coyotes. I knew and old poacher in the Sierra Madre Mtns. of Wyoming who took piles of elk with a Swift.;)

Cheever 12-08-2013 08:22 AM

I just inherited a trapdoor carbine replica in 45-70, and I was surprised that the felt recoil was less than the .44 Mag Ruger deerfield rifle I also inherited. I am impressed with the 45-70, it is amazing what can be done with it. I also have a Siamese Mauser I purchased years ago and barreled to 45-70. I have yet to put a stock on it, but once it is done I should be able to rival the .458 WM. I have yet to start reloading for it but for a cartridge that has (arguably) taken more buffalo than any other cartridge I really like it (despite being a very short guy). It is a fun cartridge to shoot.

mseric 12-08-2013 02:51 PM

I don't own a 45-70 or even a lever gun. Never found the need or desire, until now.

I feel I should have at least one rifle that shoots lead bullets well. I'm thinkin a Marlin in 45-70 is right up my ally, but I don't know much about these rifles or the cartridge. I could use some help.

Besides being belted instead of rimmed and 100fps, what is the difference between 450 Marlin and the 45-70? Does one feed better or worse than the other?

Help me decide.

nitestalker 12-08-2013 03:02 PM

The 45-70 was too late to have killed more Buffalo than any other round. It was created by the Army in 1873. It was a few years later before it became a civilian caliber. The Buffalo hunting period had mostly wound down by 1878.
I have been a fan of the 45-70 going back to 1963. I own a number of them. I also like the more traditional "Bison" busters created by the Sharps Rifle co. The 45-110-550 Sharps is my favorite.:)

Axxe55 12-08-2013 03:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by nitestalker (Post 1452606)
The 45-70 was too late to have killed more Buffalo than any other round. It was created by the Army in 1873. It was a few years later before it became a civilian caliber. The Buffalo hunting period had mostly wound down by 1878.
I have been a fan of the 45-70 going back to 1963. I own a number of them. I also like the more traditional "Bison" busters created by the Sharps Rifle co. The 45-110-550 Sharps is my favorite.:)

IIRC, aren't all of those cartridges related, the 45-70, the 45-90 and the 45-110?

same caliber and basic case dimensions other than length and powder charge?


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:38 AM.

Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.