[Scratchammo]

Checking the poll made me laugh. Still unsure

[taztown]

Go with the Benelli, I did and I love it! The ghost ring sight is great.

[Chandler51]

Benelli......

[cottontop]

Thye Benelli hands down. You can field strip it including the bolt in about 30 seconds, clean it, and out it back together in less than 5 minutes. But, thats just one positive attribute it has. It has many more.
cottontop

[PanBaccha]

Both shotguns are nicely made by reputable companies. However, I am partial toward the Mossberg 590A1 simply because I had just purchased one last week.

[303tom]

Mossberg..................

[Eattheham]

While both guns are very nice I would have to say mossberg

[tonydewar]

both are solid do you want to drive a vw or a porsch?

[Buckethead47]

Originally Posted by tonydewar

both are solid do you want to drive a vw or a porsch?

More like ford vs ferrari. The 500/590 is like a 4 door pickup, a versatile workhorse. Good for anything you throw at it. The benelli is more high end sports car. Something breaks you have to buy from the dealership. I rarely see anything for benelli cheap. The 590 you could make it do anything you want with the change of a barrel, and twist of a choke. I rarely see chokes for that gun, but when I do they are expensive. If you have the money go for it. In the end you have to be happy with your purchase not us. Go to a fun store and pick them both up.

[rjgnwdc]

Here's mine great shooter never fails easy break down and it's quite the looker