Firearm & Gun Forum - FireArmsTalk.com

Firearm & Gun Forum - FireArmsTalk.com (http://www.firearmstalk.com/forums/)
-   Concealed Carrying & Personal Protection (http://www.firearmstalk.com/forums/f17/)
-   -   Leather vs Kydex/Blade-Tech (Plastic) (http://www.firearmstalk.com/forums/f17/leather-vs-kydex-blade-tech-plastic-103542/)

wittmeba 02-02-2014 01:09 AM

Leather vs Kydex/Blade-Tech (Plastic)
 
I've been reading a lot about the various carry techniques, holsters and guns best suited for CCW.

But I need to hear from those that have had both reasonably good leather holsters and also Kydex/Blade-Tech (plastic) holsters.

I hope Kydex isn't the best there is because I'm a little disappointed if that's the case. There seems to be several who use Kydex/Blade-Tech on another form of backing but I'm more interested in a true leather for OWB carrying.

Mine is a Blade-Tech and doesn't fit my body correctly (or my body doesn't fit it correctly), not easily re-holstered and causes the gun grip to stick out toward the side a bit more than I prefer. I'm hoping a good fitting leather will allow my belt to pull it against my hip and will better conceal when just wearing a long shirt.

The one's I've found most attractive are the Belt Slides - Galco, Bianchi Paddles, some from Holsterama (JBP) and Falco. Lots of other very beautiful leather but many are out of my price range.

Any guidance on paddle, pancake or belt slide will be appreciated.

How do leather paddles compare to Kydex/Blade-tech plastics?

Mercator 02-02-2014 01:18 AM

Leather, especially new, provides retention. Kydex is rigid and should release the gun easily, but has to be molded and fitted just so. Kydex holsters typically have retention tabs. You might also consider moving the holster on your waist to find a sweet spot. Say mine is at about 4:30, others feel better having it at 3 or on the weak side, etc. Paddles limit your placement somewhat, so I'd consider a belt holster first.

TerryM 02-02-2014 01:39 AM

Leather for IWB for me. Kydex OWB if I am near water of any kind. Fishing or boating only because I hate getting a good leather holster wet. Plus you cant beat the smell of good leather when it is new. No smell to plastic:eek:

Mercator 02-02-2014 02:08 AM

I sure don't want to smell anything on your waist :D

Kydex is better concealable OWB. No leather is as thin and strong. But that wasn't the question, so ignore at your peril... :D

wittmeba 02-13-2014 12:49 AM

Been looking hard at AlienGear (actually placed an order last Friday) when I stumbled upon Old Faithful Holsters.

These two are exactly alike. I mean the leather, Kydex, hardware screws, washers, color, options, warranty and try for 30 days option. You can get all the pieces to assemble your own if you want from either business.

Anyone familiar with either company? I just wonder who is copying who? This is not a fluke. I'd love to learn anything about either/both companies.

http://aliengearholsters.com/

http://oldfaithfulholsters.com/

wittmeba 02-15-2014 01:20 PM

I am pretty burned-out on my holster search. Just can't find anything that is the "best" for me.

I have the Blade-Tech that comes with the M&P .40 range kit (holster, 2 additional mags, Uplula speed loader) - belt attachment only. I have worn it a few times under long light shirts but the grip heal sticks out more than I want.

I thought the AlienGear IWB would be a good choice for CWC until I saw this picture and the guys write up. I couldn't deal with it.
http://s19.postimg.org/o6ttgex0j/image.jpg

I had one on order - 3-4 weeks delivery. Decided to cancel the order and I ordered a paddle attachment for the Blade-Tech. It should certainly make putting it on/off much simpler if nothing else. It might pull the holster a bit closer to my hip and reduce the protrusion of the grip. Cheapest option for me at this time - pure economics.

Now I'm thinking if I had a left hand Blade-Tech shell I could use the attachment side to attach 2 metal clips (buy at hardware store) and just glue a large piece of soft material to the other side and use it for a IWB holster. I know they are offered but I'm trying to do as much myself and save some $$$.

Mercator 02-16-2014 02:49 PM

I think its a good idea, if you want Kydex IWB. A self adhesive "no scratch" felt pad should stick well to Kydex.

Blade Tech was pleasant to deal with. They did not list my exact model, but offered to adjust the mold for it, and did fine.

Rick1967 02-16-2014 04:18 PM

A paddle is actually more versatile than a belt holster. I have seen people put the paddle between their belt and their pants. I have no idea why they use them that way. I wear a belt. But the paddle goes inside my pants. That way the belt loops do not limit where you can place the holster. Also if you need to remove a paddle holster it can be done in seconds without removing your belt.

wittmeba 02-16-2014 07:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mercator (Post 1507831)
I think its a good idea, if you want Kydex IWB. A self adhesive "no scratch" felt pad should stick well to Kydex.

Just what I'm thinking. The reason for a lefty version is to put the holes on the outermost side to add belt-clips.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Rick1967 (Post 1507910)
A paddle is actually more versatile than a belt holster. I have seen people put the paddle between their belt and their pants. I have no idea why they use them that way. I wear a belt. But the paddle goes inside my pants. That way the belt loops do not limit where you can place the holster. Also if you need to remove a paddle holster it can be done in seconds without removing your belt.

Yes...just looped over their belt.

Complete with a paddle:
http://shop.blade-tech.com/revolution-94045-p-384.html#!prettyPhoto[Product]/2/

Yeah...it would be like just dropping something in your pocket (inside your pants). I have a paddle on order for my existing Blade-Tech - should be here in less than a week.

I'd like to get a couple Blade-Tech shells to do some development/experimenting with.

John_Deer 02-22-2014 02:20 PM

I have a plain ole nylon Blackhawk paddle holster. It is one of the more comfortable holsters I own. If the belly band was not working so well, the cheapo Blackhawk would be my EDC. That says a lot about the concept of a paddle holster.

wittmeba, your body type doesn't flatter a gun carried at 3 o'clock. We all hate doing this, but you will conceal a gun better at 1 or 2 o'clock.


All times are GMT. The time now is 12:52 PM.

Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.