I would always take the Italian Beretta over the US made. Things are done different in Italy. Most US workers are slackers. Lets be men and admit that.
--Off Topic--that is the real reason all our jobs are being moved overseas.
But in Italy they go to work and they love it. Each Beretta is handled and cared for with love and passion. A priest even bless every new batch!! US workers are off sleeping in a corner or taking the "Union Break". Quality is much higher in Italy. Haven't you noticed thats why they make ferrari, lamborghini, louis vuitton, and the list goes on and on. Everything they make is made to last and of the worlds best craftsmanship.
So in closing get the Beretta made in Italy.