Firearm & Gun Forum - FireArmsTalk.com

Firearm & Gun Forum - FireArmsTalk.com (http://www.firearmstalk.com/forums/)
-   Semi-Auto Handguns (http://www.firearmstalk.com/forums/f15/)
-   -   narrowing things down a bit...maybe; need to choose a caliber (http://www.firearmstalk.com/forums/f15/narrowing-things-down-bit-maybe-need-choose-caliber-36541/)

Owl1024 01-07-2011 12:53 PM

narrowing things down a bit...maybe; need to choose a caliber
 
OK, so I've decided to trade in my BRICK...also known as my S&W Sigma SW9VE. I may have to 'save my pennies' for my replacement pistol, but first, it would help if I settled on a caliber....40 S&W or .45 GAP? I haven't been to my gun shop yet, but (I hope) I've narrowed my 'candidate pistols' down to these:

Springfield XD SC .40: Overall Length: 6.25 inches; Weight: 26.5 oz.; Trigger Pull: 5.5 - 7.7 lbs.***

Glock 23: Overall Length: 6.85 inches; Weight: 21.16 oz.; Trigger Pull: 5.5 lbs. ? ***

Glock 27: Overall Length: 6.29 inches; Overall Weight: 19.7/21.87; Trigger Pull: 5.5 lbs. ? ***

Glock 30: Overall Length: 6.77": Weight: ; 23.99 oz; Trigger Pull: 5.5 lbs. ***

Glock 38 .45 GAP; Overall Length: 6.85"; Weight: 24.16 oz.; Trigger Pull: 5.5 lbs. ***

Glock 39 .45 GAP; Overall Length: ; 6.30"; Weight:19.33 oz. ; Trigger Pull: 5.5 lbs.

I have no special affection for Glocks; they just seem to be the 'standard' against which all other pistols are measured. So, first, as someone coming from a 9mm pistol, which of the two calibers mentioned above would have less felt recoil, choosing from one of those 6 pistols? I understand that heavier guns absorb recoil better, but my pistol will also be my EDC. So, which of those six is the best 'balance' of size/weight on one hand, and least 'muzzle flip'/most controllability?

If it helps, I'm 5' 7" tall and weigh about 165 pounds.

Many thanks for your input.

NGIB 01-07-2011 01:00 PM

The first thing I'd do is price ammo in your area. In many places, .45 GAP is hard to find and expensive. Smallish .40s are very snappy and not the easiest guns to shoot well. You will want to try out a Glock before you buy one as they don't work well for some folks - me included. The grip angle is unique and the finger grooves are either loved or hated.

All the guns you list will recoil more than your Sigma, the Glock 23 would probably be the softest shooting of the bunch IMHO...

DrJason 01-07-2011 01:22 PM

I would echo what NGIB said.

I am curious as to why you are not considering staying with 9mm?

Owl1024 01-07-2011 01:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrJason (Post 416932)
I would echo what NGIB said.

I am curious as to why you are not considering staying with 9mm?

Everything I've read says 9 mm doesn't have sufficient, '1-shot stop' capability; so, I'm now exploring .40 S&W and .45 G. A. P.

NGIB 01-07-2011 01:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Owl1024 (Post 416940)
Everything I've read says 9 mm doesn't have sufficient, '1-shot stop' capability; so, I'm now exploring .40 S&W and .45 G. A. P.

No standard pistol caliber has a guaranteed 1 shot stop capability - none, period, end of story.

If you do your part, any caliber from .380 on up will provide you with adequate defensive capability. Don't get trapped by the interwebz caliber wars as the perfect caliber does not exist. Practice is much more important than caliber and choosing a pricey round like the .45 GAP makes practice expensive. Also many smallish large caliber guns are not enjoyable to shoot - which makes folks practice less.

Your 9mm is just fine as a defensive gun...

Owl1024 01-07-2011 01:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NGIB (Post 416920)
The first thing I'd do is price ammo in your area. In many places, .45 GAP is hard to find and expensive. Smallish .40s are very snappy and not the easiest guns to shoot well. You will want to try out a Glock before you buy one as they don't work well for some folks - me included. The grip angle is unique and the finger grooves are either loved or hated.

All the guns you list will recoil more than your Sigma, the Glock 23 would probably be the softest shooting of the bunch IMHO...

My preferred retailers are all online: Ammo-to-Go; Midway USA; Natchez.

spittinfire 01-07-2011 01:51 PM

I personally would steer clear of 45gap. It's expensive to shoot, hard to find ammo and you'll have a hard time selling the gun should you ever want to. If you want a 45, go acp.

I'll echo NGIB, I think 9mm is fine for self defense. I carry a 45 but have carried a 9mm and a 38 and never felt unsafe. IMHO, anything from 380/38 and up will serve you well in a defensive situation. Practice and familiarity with your weapon will go a long way over a larger caliber in a weapon you aren't familiar with.

DrJason 01-07-2011 01:56 PM

I feel like NGIB's shadow and echo on this thread. I personally choose the 9mm for cost, availability, and ease of shooting. Obviously there is no such thing as the "perfect" caliber all have compromises.

Gojubrian 01-07-2011 02:10 PM

9mm is fine for a defensive weapon, like everyone is saying. My bedside companion was my cz75b 9mm for a long time and I never felt under armed.

Practice shot placement and follow up shots for defensive protection. This is done best with practice and 9mm is cheaper to buy.

The sigma is fine for what you want. Unless you just want to change things up and get a different gun that is.

Having said all of that I carry an xd40sc. ;)

http://i699.photobucket.com/albums/v...31/guns003.jpg

JTJ 01-07-2011 02:44 PM

Rather than the 45 gap look at the Glock 36 in 45 acp. 27oz fully loaded with 6+1. They are slightly thinner than the G23 etc.


All times are GMT. The time now is 08:51 PM.

Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.