I vote Crossbreed. I have several Crossbreed holsters and 2 Minotaurs. The minotaurs are very well made and finished but don't have as long a length, so the don't "spread the weight" like a Crossbreed does. I prefer Theis, Old Faithful, Shepherd Leather to the Comp-tac's, for the same reason. I have a MTAC for an XD 45 Service/Compact, Right Hand shooter, with C-mounts that I'll be happy to sell you, cheap. It'll probably work for you.