Originally Posted by Planejain
It was mein kampf to have to choose which version to post on here, and I ended up picking with the more modern version only because of its color, and how many people don't really get into the old films as much as we should.
Understood. My quarrel with the remake is that the dialogue doesn't seem believable ; too perfect, too Hollywood . That and the way they had to hit you over the head to make you understand the point ; pure Hollywood again .
Civil War Movies :
I hope they don't remake " Gone With the Wind ", probably the best Civil War movie of all time .
" Gettysburg " was historically accurate but Martin Sheen was horrible as Robert E. Lee .
" Glory " , the story of the black soldiers who attacked Fort Wagner was highly fictionalized . It included a fictional racist white quartermaster guaranteed to reinforce some black viewers' conceptions of rampant white racism . Blending fact and fiction is a dangerous business
and is why I didn't include this movie as one I'd recommend .
" Cold Mountain ", starring Nicole Kidman , featured sadistic scenes and anachronistic language . It was a bad movie with a good opening scene
, which shows the Petersburg mine explosion and the Union failure to breech the confederate lines . The actors for this scene were Romanian soldiers and it was shot in Romania . In real life, a lot of the Union troops were black .
" The Birth of a Nation " made movie history but also made heroes out of the Klansmen . It is a classic of cinematography but a distorted, racist depiction of the war's end and Reconstruction .
" The Good, The Bad, and the Ugly " was a bad movie
with a wildly fanciful civil war battle scene in which Union troops employ Gatling guns to mow down Confederates . Nothing is getting accomplished and the movie's anti-war message shines through .